H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[iceymoon]

i did the idol sorting thing again, and it was slightly wrong.. i always feel like my split-second decisions don't quit get how i feel when i consider things more carefully (and see the full list and think either "that feels right" or "no, something is off..").

so i adjusted it slightly. i still feel like something is off, but i think that's because several of the members (especially after #16) are in a transition period for me. so it's accurate for now, but will be changing for a while.

(it's an image because it lets me think about it more visually)

Spoiler: show

my top 5 are so far above everyone else, i think it'll stay that way for the foreseeable future.
i wonder what will happen once 11th gen comes in...

[wotakubrandon]

Oooh, what idol sorting thing?

[iceymoon]

http://usachan-peace.jpn.org/hello/sort/sort.html
it's just a list though. i used the photos so i could mess with it in photoshop more easily (plus it looks nicer). :]

[esm]

My top 8 (was going to do 10, but #9 and 10 seem so far apart from the top 8 )

1. Ikuta Erina
2. Tanaka Reina
3. Sayashi Riho
4. Natsuyaki Miyabi
5. Suzuki Airi
6. Tsugunaga Momoko　
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Yajima Maimi

[wotakubrandon]

1. Ikuta Erina
2. Natsuyaki Miyabi
3. Captain Saki
4. Princess Mizuki
5. Harunan
6. Maasa
7. Chinami
8. DJ MaiMai
9. Robo-Masaki
10. Socko

I'm kind of surprised actually. Not with top 3 but everything after that.
Except for the very bottom. That's all S/milage and RihoReina.

[Starra]

My top ten according to that:
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Sayashi Riho
3. Sudou Maasa
4. Hagiwara Mai
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Fukuda Kanon
7. Tamura Meimi
8. Tsugunaga Momoko
9. Tanaka Reina
10. Sugaya Risako

Actually pretty damn accurate, except that I have no idea how Reina got that high.

The rest:

Spoiler: show

11. Nakanishi Kana
12. Suzuki Kanon
13. Mano Erina
14. Wada Ayaka
15. Michishige Sayumi
16. Katsuta Rina
17. Nakajima Saki
18. Fukumura Mizuki
19. Yajima Maimi
20. Ikuta Erina
21. Kumai Yurina
22. Tokunaga Chinami
23. Suzuki Airi
24. Shimizu Saki
25. Takeuchi Akari　
26. Satou Masaki
27. Natsuyaki Miyabi
28. Okai Chisato
29. Kudou Haruka

Haruka should be above Chisato and Miyabi, and Eripon and Mizuki should be swapped. But other than that, yeah, it's accurate.


My actual top ten:
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Sayashi Riho
3. Sudou Maasa
4. Hagiwara Mai
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Miyamoto Karin (she counts in my book okay)
7. Tsugunaga Momoko
8. Fukuda Kanon
9. Tamura Meimi
10. Sugaya Risako

[Sohee]

1. Michishige Sayumi
2. Tanaka Reina
3. Sugaya Risako
4. Fukumura Mizuki
5. Satou Masaki
6. Ikuta Erina
7. Suzuki Kanon
8. Hagiwara Mai
9. Takeuchi Akari
10. Suzuki Airi

Quite accurate I guess. Surprised at the lack of Chisato... but she was down at #12 so I guess it might make sense. xD

Bottom:

Spoiler: show

24. Tokunaga Chinami
25. Nakanishi Kana
26. Katsuta Rina
27. Sudou Maasa
28. Tamura Meimi
29. Kudou Haruka

[Rm88]

My top 10 turned out quite accurate:

1- Momoko
2- Chinami
3- Yurina
4- Captain
5- Risako
6- Maasa
7- Kanana
8- Miyabi
9- Takechan
10- Dawa

Spoiler: show

11- Kanyon
12- Mano
13- Sayumi
14- Ayumi
15- Riho
16- Zukki
17- Meimi <<< should be in Riho's place, I think
18- Rina
19- Airi
20- Reina
21- Eripon
22- Mizuki
23- Nakki
24- Haruka
25- Mai
26- Masaki
27- Haruna
28- Maimi
29- Chisato

[AyuHikaru]

According to that thing:

1. Haruna Iikubo
2. Ayumi Ishida
3. Risako Sugaya
4. Kanon Suzuki
5. Masaki Sato
6. Miyabi Natsuyaki
7. Haruka Kudo
8. Riho Sayashi
9. Mai Hagiwara
10. Airi Suzuki

That's about right, though I'm not sure if Haruka beats Riho at this point. Miyabi and Risako have gone up my ranking by a lot the last 6 months. I really love them <3. The first S'mileage girl makes her appearence at 14 (Dawa)

Here's the rest of the list:

Spoiler: show

11. Chisato Okai
12. Reina Tanaka
13. Sayumi Michishige
14. Ayaka Wada
15. Chinami Tokunaga
16. Maasa Sudo
17. Meimi Tamura
18. Saki Nakajima
19. Kana Nakanishi
20. Erina Ikuta
21. Kanon Fukuda
22. Momoko
23. Takechan
24. Captain
25. Mizupon
26. Maimi Yajima
27. Yurina Kumai
28. Erina Mano
29. Rinapuu

I'm not sure where Aika would be, actually. Guess I have to wait till she gets added.

[Nayoko-Kihara]

I've tried that sorting thing a few times, but somehow things always get mixed up in the process and my ranking comes out weird.