by Shoujo Q » Thu Jul 15, 2021 11:22 pm
It's interesting to watch it (UF) evolve over the years and if you're coming in as a fan now, that's really all you see. What you mention, the high-class part. But as a long time fan where the original mentality was that we were taking these losers and making them into first class idols, it's a little bit jarring really. And something I need to get use too. Will we ever see girls like Konno, Koharu, (both) Harunas, Hagiwara making their debut in H!P or will they be relegated to Kenshuusei status from here on out?
I feel 'personally' almost like the K-pop model has really made this the new norm. You have girls who train for YEARS to debut and then are presented off as these super polished idols with very little flaws. And in doing so, you lose a bit of that home grown aspect to the idols which I always found endearing. Like a proud parent watching their little bird finally achieve their goals. In a way, that will always be a very Japanese way to look at idols and it's one I very much prefer. But that polished idol look is really creeping in and honestly, I'm not sure where I was going with any of this, but I guess I just had to vent about the state of idols right now.
I guess that's why indie idols are still very much a popular thing.