H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[Rm88]

Ranking update, with score:

Berry Koubou: 4.92/5
1- Momoko 5
2- Chinami 5
3- Captain 5
4- Yurina 5
5- Risako 5
6- Maasa 5
7- Miyabi 4.5

S/mileage: 4.14/5
1- Yuuka 5
2- Dawa 5
3- Kanon 4.5
4- Takechan 4.5
5- Rina 3.5
6- Kana 3.5
7- Meimi 3

Morning Musume: 2.68/5
1- Mizuki 4
2- Sayumi 4
3- Reina 3.5
4- Riho 3.5
5- Kanon 3
6- Aika 1.5
7- Erina 1
8- Risa 1

C-ute: 2/5
1- Nakki 3
2- Airi 3
3- Chisato 1.5
4- Mai 1.5
5- Maimi 1

Mano: 4.5/5

[Amped]

Haruka
Haruna
Gaki-san
Fuku-chan
Eripon
Masaki
Riho
Sayumi
Reina
Aichan
Zukki
Ayumi
Aika

Haruka has become my top favorite over Gaki-san


Sakura Gumi - Gaki (Leader), Fuku-chan, Aika, Masaki, Haruka, Eripon
Otome Gumi - Sayumi (Leader), Reina, Riho, Ayumi, Haruna, Zukki

[Naomi]

My new ranking, too. Last one featuring Aichan. ;-;

01. Niigaki Risa
02. Tanaka Reina
03. Takahashi Ai
04. Ishida Ayumi
05. Ikuta Erina
06. Michishige Sayumi
07. Kudou Haruka
08. Sayashi Riho
09. Fukumura Mizuki
10. Iikubo Haruna
11. Suzuki Kanon
12. Sato Masaki
13. Mitsui Aika

I don't know if Ayu will ever beat Gaki since Gaki's been my favorite for several years, but soon-to-be 3rd isn't bad for a girl I know almost nothing of. xD I think the other three can definitely grow on me, so their positions aren't definite.

And while I'm at it, I'm just going to do a full ranking since I like to rank things.

01. Niigaki Risa
01. Okai Chisato
03. Tanaka Reina
04. Takahashi Ai
05. Suzuki Airi
06. Nakajima Saki
07. Ishida Ayumi
08. Hagiwara Mai
09. Natsuyaki Miyabi
10. Yajima Maimi
11. Ikuta Erina
12. Michishige Sayumi
13. Maeda Yuuka
14. Kudou Haruka
15. Fukuda Kanon
16. Sayashi Riho
17. Sudou Maasa
18. Fukumura Mizuki
19. Tokunaga Chinami
20. Tsugunaga Momoko
21. Wada Ayaka
22. Iikubo Haruna
23. Shimizu Saki
24. Suzuki Kanon
25. Sato Masaki
26. Kumai Yurina
27. Mano Erina
28. Mitsui Aika
29. Sugaya Risako

[Starra]

1. Sayashi Riho

2. Ishida Ayumi

3. Mitsui Aika
4. Niigaki Risa
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Ikuta Erina

7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Fukumura Mizuki
9. Satou Masaki

10. Tanaka Reina
11. Suzuki Kanon

12. Kudou Haruka

[iceymoon]

i'll do my ranking too, just so i can remember how i felt about them as Aichan was graduation and juukies were joining.

1. Michishige Sayumi
2. Niigaki Risa

3. Takahashi Ai

4. Sayashi Riho
5. Ikuta Erina
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Kudou Haruka

8. Ishida Ayumi
9. Fukumura Mizuki
10. Iikubo Haruna

11. Suzuki Kanon

12. Mitsui Aika
13. Satou Masaki

i like all of them up until Kanon, but to different extents.

top two have been the same since Eri and JunJun left. liking Gaki more recently. <3

Riho for me has fallen under Aichan because, even though i fangirled her in the auditions, she hasn't shown me that extra factor that would put her in the same league. it took yeaaaars for Aichan to gain it herself, though, so i think she'll have it one day.

i don't remember my last ranking, but Eripon has firmly planted herself above Reina. i have the feeling the same thing will happen with Harurun once i get to know her better. x3

8-10 are a little weird.. i liked Mizuki from the beginning (enough to show her picture to Bryan when i was speculating what eggs have potential to be added to MM), but even though i collect pictures and stuff, i can't justify putting her higher in the ranking. she's missing a more magnetic quality to make me a bigger fan. in fact, Ishida Ayumi has already passed her (on potential alone, i will have to see how i feel about her once she's fully in the group).

i also like Iikubo Haruna, but have to see more of her to have a stronger opinion.

i find Kanon funny and entertaining, while at the same time a little irritating. i don't like idols that can't pull off being more graceful or charming (to put this in context, i don't much care for Mako or Keichan). she's entertaining enough for me not to dislike her, but at the same time i can't rank her higher.. she's a comedic brat like Tsuji/Kago used to be, only less adorable and lovable. maybe she just needs time to grow into a little bit more of a mature/cute version of what she is now.

this is the first time Aika has not been at the very bottom since she joined, i think that's because i'm still unhappy with a sub-par member being there instead of Sara. i have no idea where Masaki will go from here, though, could go up.. or fortify herself on the bottom lol.

[Sohee]

I'll do it just because. Judging the 10th mostly because of looks though.

1. Michishige Sayumi
2. Takahashi Ai
3. Niigaki Risa

5. Tanaka Reina
6. Suzuki Kanon
7. Ikuta Erina
8. Iikubo Haruna
9. Sayashi Riho

10. Ishida Ayumi
11. Mitsui Aika
12. Fukumura Mizuki

13. Kudou Haruka

[Mirai]

I'll do my final ranking with Ai / first with 10th gen too.

1. Ai Takahashi
2. Risa Niigaki
3. Reina Tanaka
4. Sayumi Michishige
5. Aika Mitsui
6. Erina Ikuta
7. Riho Sayashi
8. Kanon Suzuki
9. Mizuki Fukumura
10. Ayumi Ishida
11. Haruna Iikubo
12. Haruka Kudou
13. Masaki Satou

Risa and Reina are actually about even, I keep flip flopping on who I like the best...

[321BreakinOut]

1.Ai
2.Riho
3.Mizuki
4.Sayumi
5.Erina
6.Risa
7.Reina
8.Kanon
9.Aika

10th gen:

10.Haruka
11.Ayumi / Haruna
12.Masaki

[SweetBene]

Now Ai is gone, MM raking time :

1. Sayashi Riho
2. Mitsui Aika
3. Kudou Haruka
4. Niigaki Risa
5. Ikuta Erina
6. Fukumura Mizuki
7. Ishida Ayumi
8. Satou Masaki
9. Michishige Sayumi
10. Suzuki Kanon
11. Iikubo Haruna
12. Tanaka Reina

[esm]

Ai-chan leadership era singles

1. Kare to Issho ni Omise ga Shitai
2. Kono Chikyuu no Heiwa wo Honki de Negatterun da yo!
3. Mikan
4. Maji desu ka Ska!
5. Seishun Collection
6. Naichau Kamo
7. Onna ni Sachi are
8. Resonant Blue
9. Nanchatte Renai
10. Only You
11. Onna to Otoko no Lullaby Game
12. Shouganai Yume Oibito
13. Pepper Keibu
14. Kimagure Princess
15. Onna ga Medatte Naze Ikenai