H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[Sohee]

MM'17 ranking using this sort: http://sort.nobody.jp/musume/

1. Maachan
2. Mizuki
3. Sakura
4. Kaede
5. Ayumi
6. Haruka
7. Maria
8. Yokoyan
9. Ogata
10. Ikuta
11. Haga
12. Iikubo
13. Nonaka

[Shoujo Q]

1. Sakura
2. Mizuki
3. Kaede
4. Haruka
5. Masaki
6. Reina
7. Iikubo
8. Nonaka
9. Ayumi
10. Akane
11. Ogata
12. Maria
13. Ikuta

Ikuta's low energy may be appealing to some, but in an idol group, I don't think it's cool. On the other hand, Maria is cute but she still hasn't won me over.

Kaede, Mizuki and Haruka are pretty much in flux. I still haven't found my solid #2 since Zukki left and those three have been messing with my ranking ever since. Vocally I prefer Mizuki but by sheer will Kaede wins my heart. And Reina is starting to creep in too. She's got an infectious smile, but her vocal talents are what put you in my top 5. So I'll need to give her the standard year I give all newbies before I really have a solid space for her and Kaede. If Nonaka can hammer out a decent character for herself, she might move up too. But her awkwardness is really a drawback for me.

[Rysaria]

Well with the new addition and time passing...

1. Ogata
2. Ayumi
3. Masaki
4. Kaede
5. Maria
6. Reina
7. Iikubo
8. Sakura
9. Haruka
10. Erina
11. Akane
12. Miki
13. Mizuki

5-9 are all really about same level for me, I really like those girls. I flip back and forth on Erina depending on if she's being a narcissist/singing and Akane is a cute blank slate so I can't do anything now but like her voice and wait for its improvement and eventual good use in songs.

[Zunu]

Same tool.

1. Maachan
2. Oda
3. Ikuta
4. Mizupon
5. Haruka
6. Reina
7. Kaedy
8. Ayumi
9. Ogata
10. Nonaka
11. Iikubo
12. Akane
13. Maria

I'm a bit surprised tbh that Maria ended up on the bottom. I guess the problem for me is that other than being pretty she's got no attributes that stand out.

[Amped]

TBS Rank Oukoku 5/20/17

at Budokan Idol Expo 2017 event on 5/6, 100 active idols were polled : "Your ideal no.1 Idol?"





AKB - 18%
Morning Musume. '17 - 14%
Momoiro Clover Z - 5%
Nogizaka - 5%
Dempa gumi inc. - 4%
Other - 54%

over 1,000 idols from over 200 idol groups gathered at the Budokan Idol Expo 2017 during Golden Week, to interact with fans.

[Celedam]

^ That's not bad at all.

And I'd bet that approximately 10 of the other 54 percent comprises the remaining H!P groups.

[BerryzCelebration]

H!P Groups Member Rankings (based on sorter) link: http://sort.gq

Spoiler: show

Tsubaki Factory:
1.) Ono Mizuho
2.) Niinuma Kisora
3.) Kishimoto Yumeno
4.) Yamagishi Riko
5.) Akiyama Mao
6.) Onoda Saori
7.) Tanimoto Ami
8.) Asakura Kiki
9.) Ogata Risa

Juice=Juice
1.) Uemura Akari
2.) Takagi Sayuki
3.) Miyazaki Yuka
4.) Kanazawa Tomoko
5.) Miyamoto Karin

Country Girls:
1.) Funaki Musubu
2.) Tsugunaga Momoko ;_;
3.) Yamaki Risa
4.) Ozeki Mai
5.) Morito Chisaki
6.) Yanagawa Nanami

Kobushi Factory
1.) Wada Sakurako
2.) Nomura Minami
3.) Fujii Rio ;_;
4.) Inoue Rei
5.) Hamaura Ayano
6.) Hirose Ayaka
7.) Taguchi Natsumi
8.) Ogawa Rena

C-ute ;;_;;
1.) Nakajima Saki
2.) Okai Chisato
3.) Suzuki Airi
4.) Hagiwara Mai
5.) Yajima Maimi

ANGERME
1.) Aikawa Maho ;_;
2.) Kasahara Momona
3.) Murota Mizuki
4.) Nakanishi Kana
5.) Takeuchi Akari
6.) Wada Ayaka
7.) Katsuta Rina
8.) Kamikokuryou Moe
9.) Sasaki Rikako

Morning Musume. '17
1.) Ikuta Erina
2.) Haga Akane
3.) Ishida Ayumi
4.) Nonaka Miki
5.) Makino Maria
6.) Kudo Haruka ;_;
7.) Kaga Kaede
8.) Fukumura Mizuki
9.) Yokoyama Reina
10.) Oda Sakura
11.) Ogata Haruna
12.) Iikubo Haruna
13.) Sato Masaki

H!P Groups in general:
1.) Juice=Juice <3
2.) Country Girls
3.) ANGERME
4.) Morning Musume 17
5.) Tsubaki Factory
6.) Kobushi Factory

[Shoujo Q]

The ranker has been updated with the removal of C-ute. Time to do a new ranking. T_T

[aerosuffly]

Can I ask how those Japanese ranking like the two above work?

[Starra]

Did the sort (with Kenshuusei):

Spoiler: show

1. Ogata Haruna
2. Kanazawa Tomoko
3. Kaga Kaede
4. Yanagawa Nanami
5. Kamikokuryou Moe
6. Yamazaki Mei
7. Kiyono Momohime
8. Kishimoto Yumeno
9. Sayashi Riho
10. Kasahara Momona
11. Onoda Saori
12. Miyazaki Yuka
13. Ishida Ayumi
14. Miyamoto Karin
15. Iikubo Haruna
16. Wada Sakurako
17. Ono Mizuho
18. Ozeki Mai
19. Nonaka Miki
20. Aikawa Maho
21. Nakanishi Kana
22. Yonemura Kirara
23. Hamaura Ayano
24. Uemura Akari
25. Hashisako Rin
26. Kawamura Ayano
27. Kitagawa Ryou
28. Danbara Ruru
29. Yamazaki Yuhane
30. Morito Chisaki
31. Murota Mizuki
32. Yamada Ichigo
33. Kanatsu Mizuki
34. Doi Rena
35. Nomura Minami
36. Kudou Yume
37. Matsunaga Riai
38. Ogata Risa
39. Haga Akane
40. Takeuchi Akari
41. Mitsui Aika
42. Makino Maria
43. Akiyama Mao
44. Kudou Haruka
45. Funaki Musubu
46. Nakayama Natsume
47. Okamura Minami
48. Shimakura Rika
49. Tanimoto Ami
50. Niinuma Kisora
51. Satou Hikari
52. Ishiguri Kanami
53. Taguchi Natsumi
54. Eguchi Saya
55. Maeda Kokoro
56. Tsugunaga Momoko
57. Yokoyama Reina
58. Hibi Marina
59. Takagi Sayuki
60. Sasaki Rikako
61. Yamaki Risa
62. Ichioka Reina
63. Asakura Kiki
64. Kawano Minori
65. Oota Haruka
66. Ono Kotomi
67. Inoue Rei
68. Takase Kurumi
69. Yamagishi Riko
70. Fukumura Mizuki
71. Wada Ayaka
72. Horie Kizuki
73. Inoue Hikari
74. Fujii Rio
75. Noguchi Kurumi
76. Kodama Sakiko
77. Nishida Shiori
78. Ikuta Erina
79. Katsuta Rina
80. Oda Sakura
81. Satou Masaki
82. Hirose Ayaka
83. Ogawa Rena

Akane and Takechan should be much higher. Murotan, Haruka, Kiki and Ayaka should be lower.