by CaptainBerryzGiraffe » Fri Jun 19, 2015 1:02 am
So, I won't start talking about which key they are all in, i'm gonna keep it short and sweet:
In Tsunku version, the first "Koike-san" is a "D", and in the KF version it's a "G#" therefore, if that one note is higher in the KF version, then the whole song is definitely on a higher key.
As for the singing...
As for comparing the octaves, Tsunku's is still a lower pitch... If you match the note he's singing on the same octave, and then match the note the girls are singing on their octave, you have to go up in pitch to sing it, not down in pitch.
Also "range"... would mean the lowest note they sing to the highest note they sing... that's their range. Tsunku's range is 100% a lower range than KF's girls, hands down. (therefore the latter part of your hypothesis is incorrect.)
Generally, as a rule, girls sing on higher octaves than men, so for a man to sing the same line as a girl, they have to switch to a higher octave, usually hard to sing in. (it's just the way things work.) There are exceptions, obv, like men who just naturally sing in like, tenor and higher voices.
It's the same reason why so many H!P songs have male voices in the background- especially with younger girls, their voices are still in higher octaves, so they need a male voice to give the voices some depth.
(Like, in Otome no Gyakushuu when Kana does her really deep voice part at the end of the chorus, that's my regular key of singing.)
As for the instrumental itself,
whether or not that is on a higher/lower octave, would require a better listen of the instrumental. xD
(any more discussion of this, we should just quote and move to the musings/rants.)
No Berryz, No Life.
Please people, I'm a "he" not a "she".