[4/15] Morning Musume。'15 58th single "Seishun Kozou ga Naiteiru / Yuugure wa Ameagari / Ima Koko Kara"

[Parhelion69]

I actually liked Karin in MM, heck I'd love it to be a permanent member!

She is a bit enthusiastic with her moves at times, overdoing some of her movements, but nothing as bad as Takechan used to do, and that can be easily corrected.

Is it too much dreaming to ask for this?

[Echidna]

ok, I'm pissed %)))
I didn't saw that Gyao version you guys are talking about but H!S version is more than enough for me.
UF shouldn't give Karin any of those close ups, espacially when she pretending to sing lines. I never liked her and that PVs make me dislike her more plus with that haircut she looks terribly
i feel sorry for Kanon. And I'd feel the same if that "Karin-thing" happened to any other Musume.
I was waiting for PVs but now they ruined for me

[Denki]

Next time when a back member can't be featured in an MV, they should just get a KSS to replace her and not feature her in solo shots at all.

Just saying because of all of this drama over Karin solo-shots.

[Jessi]

ok, I'm pissed %)))
I didn't saw that Gyao version you guys are talking about but H!S version is more than enough for me.
UF shouldn't give Karin any of those close ups, espacially when she pretending to sing lines. I never liked her and that PVs make me dislike her more plus with that haircut she looks terribly
i feel sorry for Kanon. And I'd feel the same if that "Karin-thing" happened to any other Musume.
I was waiting for PVs but now they ruined for me

If your this upset with just the H!S version then don't ever watch the gyao version... It was much much worse. Like H!S version is a million times better.

[yukisuki]

ok, I'm pissed %)))
I didn't saw that Gyao version you guys are talking about but H!S version is more than enough for me.
UF shouldn't give Karin any of those close ups, espacially when she pretending to sing lines. I never liked her and that PVs make me dislike her more plus with that haircut she looks terribly
i feel sorry for Kanon. And I'd feel the same if that "Karin-thing" happened to any other Musume.
I was waiting for PVs but now they ruined for me

It's like you went into my head and wrote down my feelings exactly. I can't even enjoy the music videos now because of this. They'd seriously better fix this when they upload the full versions.

[AyuHikaru]

Fix WHAT? Who caaarrresssss. It's just a gimmicky fun thing they did because Kanon was out. It's not a big deal. Like, at all. Yall might have a case if Kanon wasn't out and they threw Karen in anyway. But they didn't. It's a PV, it means little to nothing - especially since that PV ain't going viral anytime soon.

How HOW was everyone praising AYUMI in the J=J video when she got the CENTER of the dance, but freaking out over KARIN. Morning Musume fans, man.

Hardcore fans getting all upset, meanwhile casual fans are going "Gee neat PV".

[Amped]

another preview of Seishun MV at 3:59 and Yuugure MV at 4:41. it still has Karin in it.
http://youtu.be/q1SqnkKuHtA?t=3m59s

there are less shots of Karin now, so it doesn't bother me as much anymore. I learned to ignore her.

[Shoujo Q]

Fix WHAT? Who caaarrresssss. It's just a gimmicky fun thing they did because Kanon was out. It's not a big deal. Like, at all. Yall might have a case if Kanon wasn't out and they threw Karen in anyway. But they didn't. It's a PV, it means little to nothing - especially since that PV ain't going viral anytime soon.

How HOW was everyone praising AYUMI in the J=J video when she got the CENTER of the dance, but freaking out over KARIN. Morning Musume fans, man.

Hardcore fans getting all upset, meanwhile casual fans are going "Gee neat PV".

Not trying to continue this argument but that statement has a logical answer.

Because Karin was still in the video spinning in a chair. And that's the point I think, of the argument. Ayumi was there, but so was Karin so in the big scheme of things it was a non-issue in that case.

[AyuHikaru]

Except Kanon couldn't even be there in close ups do to the flu. It's not like they shoved Kanon out. Context.

[yukisuki]

^^ Precisely. I get that Kanon was injured so they used Karin to take her place in the dance. But it was absolutely uncalled for that she have close ups and lip shots. She's not in the group. She doesn't even sing so why do they have shots of her lipsyncing? And Ayumi in Juice=Juice bugs me a little too. It was weird. But at least she didn't have close-ups. Imagine if at the beginning of IjiDaki's MV they showed this long close up shot of Ayumi, like the song is all about her, or shots of her lipsyncing like she is actually singing the song. That would have been stupid and ridiculous, because she's not a member of Juice=Juice, she doesn't sing. She was a replacement for the dance only, and that was how they treated her. The same rules should apply for Karin. It doesn't matter if Kanon was in the close ups or not. That doesn't change the fact that Karin should not be.