[4/15] Morning Musume。'15 58th single "Seishun Kozou ga Naiteiru / Yuugure wa Ameagari / Ima Koko Kara"

[LiamMusume]

I wonder if Karins Solo Close-up Version will be on the Event V?

[otaku_blue]

i have this theory that this preview was a rough edit. for the Ima Koko Kara PV we've had like 3 different versions shown.
there was Hello Station, a 1 minute version aired, and final version that was all different.

only thing is why even film Karin her own close-ups and image scenes? so unnecessary

[coconuts]

I wonder if this is Up-Front's subtle attempt at getting Karin fans to buy MM's single...

[Solarblade]

If theres gonna be a preview on hello! Station its prolly gonna be shorter than this preview lol

[BerryzCelebration]

I looked at Ijiwaru again, and Ayumi was showed a lot, but only in the dance version. When Karin sang her lines, they barely tried to show Ayumi, and focused on Karin and her chair. But it's different because Kanon's not there at all.

I feel so bad for Kanon. It was literally not even necessary to give Karin all of those shots. That's going to make new fans pay attention to a girl that's not even in the group.

[forgetmenots]

Wow.. did they like.. not inform the editor that Karin isn't actually in MM? It feels like they thought she was 12th Gen with all tbat screen time. Karin probably is probably feeling weird about the cut as well I bet. This is nothing like how Ayumi stepped in.

ItIt's such a same because this is one if their most beautiful PVs I've seen. The simplicity is perfect.

[jeiwa42]

Uh...this isn't good. Did she even sing any part of the song? Harmonies? Background voice? Its completely unecessary to, first of all like everyone said, have solo shots of her, and tons of em, but to have that solo shots where she's lip syncing to the song like she had any contribution to it???
Just...no...why...like I dont even remember anyone else having closeups cause she showed up so many times.
If they really wanted to, at this point they could say this song is by "Morning Musume.'15 ni Miyamoto Karin" cause like...come on...that's essentially how it looks. Heck, it'd probably be better IF they call it that if this is the real outcome for the PV, cause really, this doesnt exactly look like a "im filling in for a member just to keep the dance formation" situation, and it's kinda insulting not to address that she's not actually a part of this group, cause casual/non fans are gonna be a ton more confused.

I really hope this isnt the actual outcome. As forgetmenots said, this PV looks great, and it'd be a shame for it to be filled with closeups from a non member of the group itself. It's just not a good way to represent the group.

[Panic Nancy]

This is super great. But I'd enjoy this a lot more if there was... more hair involved.

[Starra]

She's supposed to be replacing Zukki, not everyone else too.

Nobody is going to be happy with this except antis, so it's like yo, UF, what the fuck are you doing?

[Mixi]

This is hilarious. You'd think Karin is the ace of 12th gen by the way this preview is edited. Heck, she looks like she's a lead in this single, but she has no lines. She's just a filler girl.