S/mileage new member audition!

[iceymoon]

Miyazaki - Yes please.
Kosuga - Yes please.
Yamaga - Eggs please.
Takeuchi - Yes please.
Miyamoto - Morning Musume GO.
Katsuta - Not this time, sorry.
Tamura - Eggs please.
Aogi - Yes please.
Nakanishi - Not this time, sorry.
Dayeon - Two more years practice and solo debut, or a group with Yamaga and some more, please.
Fujii - Not this time, sorry.
Ota - Yes please.

you don't like the girls i like, i think this is a first.
i freaking LOOOOVE Fujii, she's got that S/mileage spark. kind of has a Zukki vibe, personality-wise. i really think she'd fit right in!

i also liked Nakanishi, though for a je-ne-sais-quoi quality, because she didn't particularly beat the other girls at anything. she wasn't bad, though! i found her kind of cute, and though i found many of the other girls (talking non-eggs here) cute as well, i think her image fits S/mileage more than those.

egg-wise, Take-chan or Karin fit really well. i agree with Karin in MM, but if Tsunku has already mentally ruled that out then i think S/mileage would be perfect. she's got the cuteness in bucket loads!

i don't think Kosuga, Yamaga, Aogi, Dayeon or Oda fit S/mileage's image (though i like Yamaga and Aogi for H!P eggs or other groups). Tamura is cute, but i really don't want her voice in S/mileage.

we agree on Miyazaki, though. <3

[Sohee]

Fujii just annoyed me if anything. Too much "cute this cute me cute that cute them cute me cute" whatever talk for me to like it. I was honestly a bit torn on Nakanishi at first, but in the end I decided to go against it. I don't feel that she would contribute with anything at all.

I can say I honestly didn't look for "she would fit S/mileage's image" when I picked those I like. If so I think Tamura would be perfect. But I don't really like her so I don't want her in. I really want Aogi in though, and Kosuga and Miyazaki. Ota seemed really smart, and I really would love her in H!P. If she goes for eggs, I don't mind. But I wouldn't mind her in S/mileage.

I know I don't want two eggs in S/mileage. And I want only Takechan in there. If Karin got it, sure I wouldn't be angry but I really wouldn't be superhappy with it. Karin should be in Morning Musume, final. And if not that, I don't know. I really, really want Takechan in S/mileage, probably more than I want Karin in MM.

[iceymoon]

i think Takechan would be good in S/mileage, but i don't think she's all that interesting other than being kinda-cute, kinda-talented.. mostly i think her aura and image suits the group best (out of the eggs). however, Karin's got the it factor, so i really want her in *some* group, mostly MM. but the fear that if she's not gonna end up in MM this would be a lost opportunity grips me, which is why i go between maybe she should just go to S/mileage after all. >>;

i suppose i shouldn't worry about that, though, Tsunku hasn't been ignoring her, which means she'll probably end up doing something sooner or later, even if it's neither MM nor S/mileage.

[Amped]

i was focused on "she would fit S/mileage's image", and Takechan is the only one that does.

[Sohee]

I definitely think that if Karin doesn't get into MM or Smileage, she'll definitely get her own group. But I really don't want her in Smileage, no matter how much of an ace she is. I feel she definitely is a bit... too different. Even if she's cute and everything I do... think Takechan is the better choice. I don't even know why I love her so much. Like you said, she's not the best at singing nor the cutest or anything. I do think her dancing is damn good though. There's just something about her that I really, really like and I do want her in the group.

I wouldn't mind if those who don't pass to Smileage would be put in eggs, really. Yamaga for example, she needs to be in a cool/sexy/RnB unit. With Dayeon.

[Amped]

[DARC1993]

Someone needs to tell *looks at iceys chart*
Katsuta and Oda to go away .. Lol lol

[Amped]

this person put up some videos of the eggs and Dayun

group dance 1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cxFGsAcS6U8
group dance 2
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtLUAX9WWlY

Dayun
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSZUCi3dC5U

Take-chan
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59v_c85M_tE

Karin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L8RV3evCG20

Katsuta
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_GxECxABCQ

[Sohee]

I really, really like Dayeon a lot. Though she's not right for S/mileage but I really want her to debut solo or in a group within H!P in a year or two.

[Amped]

Fujii's (the small one) dancing is way out of control. she almost went to Takechan's side.