H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Morning Musume。'14, Berryz Kobo, ℃-ute, S/mileage, Juice=Juice, Hello!Project, TNX, and more

Moderator: Moh

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Zunu » Tue Sep 24, 2013 2:21 pm

Most *improved* present/former H!P member in terms of looks. Basing this on how horrifically bad they looked initially (in H!P) compared to how amazingly nice they look now (in or out of H!P) in terms of overall improvement in appearance.

1. Yurina
2. Fukuhime
3. Rinapuu
4. Koharu
5. Miyabi
6. Maana (Manami)
7. Captain
8. Ogamana
9. Risa Niigaki
10. Ayano Satou
11. Eripon

People who didn't make my list: Dawa, Maimi and Maimai were adorable kids to begin with. As far as I'm concerned, Chelsea Ching is still ugh. Nocchi :heart: , I can't really say, I'm biased.
tending to put ~ on song titles since 2002
User avatar
Zunu
Pantaloon
 
Posts: 7943
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 6:09 am
Location: miyaa planet
Has thanked: 3850 times
Been thanked: 2618 times
Favorite Idol: 能登有沙

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby resop2 » Tue Sep 24, 2013 3:08 pm

^
I'm confused, I really thought that Tsunku chose Koharu for her looks. And, I guess that Eripon and Risa must have some sort of magic working for them if they looked horrifically bad when the started and were coming off of junior modeling gigs.

However, I think that Risa commented that they wouldn't let her wear bangs until some people graduated, and didn't like showing her forehead.
User avatar
resop2
Skeptic
 
Posts: 2728
Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 10:27 am
Has thanked: 316 times
Been thanked: 388 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Zunu » Tue Sep 24, 2013 4:14 pm

resop2 wrote:^
I'm confused,


You get easily confused.
tending to put ~ on song titles since 2002
User avatar
Zunu
Pantaloon
 
Posts: 7943
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 6:09 am
Location: miyaa planet
Has thanked: 3850 times
Been thanked: 2618 times
Favorite Idol: 能登有沙

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby esm » Tue Sep 24, 2013 11:21 pm

It'd just be Chisato on that list for me.
User avatar
esm
Member
 
Posts: 2503
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2007 11:27 pm
Has thanked: 390 times
Been thanked: 660 times
Favorite Idol: Reina, Eripon, Nakky

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby sb » Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:42 am

If I made a list like that Captain would be 1 thru 4 and Risa 5 thru 8. I mean Captain didn't look human until a few years ago. Now she's one of the best in the H!P. And Risa... well my previous dislike for her is well-documented. Now she's pretty damn solid.

Rest of that list would probably be, Chinami, Kanon, and Daishi.
User avatar
sb
Minion
 
Posts: 1095
Joined: Fri Oct 14, 2011 2:27 pm
Location: A magical land.
Has thanked: 41 times
Been thanked: 256 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Parhelion69 » Thu Sep 26, 2013 12:02 am

I think Koharu looks worse now than when she joined/her first years, her face looks very weird and I wouldn't call her cute (she's got a hot bod though)
User avatar
Parhelion69
Minion
 
Posts: 1423
Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2011 1:44 am
Has thanked: 913 times
Been thanked: 196 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby otaku_blue » Thu Sep 26, 2013 10:12 am

I cry when I try to do my MM Rankings....its so hard.
Strictly speaking this is my current ranking...
1. Ayumi
2. Mizuki (there's a small difference)
3. Masaki
4. Kudou
5. Sayumi
6. Sakura
7. Haruna
8. Eripon
9. Riho
10.Zukki
otaku_blue
Devotee
 
Posts: 5880
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 9:09 pm
Has thanked: 939 times
Been thanked: 659 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby JonCC » Sun Sep 29, 2013 4:19 pm

I find it really hard to rank members. I've tried it with online rankers both with and without tie-breakers. Never got to the end of them.
So here's just a simple Yes/No. "YES" as in "good work, keep doing what you're doing" and "NO" as in "you make it hard for me to support you"
In no particular order (except age).

Morning Musume

Michishige Sayumi YES
Fukumura Mizuki YES
Ikuta Erina NO
Sayashi Riho YES
Suzuki Kanon NO
Iikubo Haruna YES
Ishida Ayumi YES
Sato Masaki YES & NO
Kudo Haruka YES
Oda Sakura YES

S/mileage

Wada Ayaka YES
Fukuda Kanon YES
Nakanishi Kana YES
Takeuchi Akari YES
Katsuta Rina YES
Tamura Meimi YES

°C-ute

Yajima Maimi YES
Nakajima Saki YES
Suzuki Airi YES
Okai Chisato NO
Hagiwara Mai NO

Berryz Kobo

Shimizu Saki YES
Tsugunaga Momoko YES
Tokunaga Chinami YES
Sudo Maasa NO
Natsuyaki Miyabi YES
Kumai Yurina YES
Sugaya Risako YES

Juice=Juice

Miyazaki Yuka YES
Kanazawa Tomoko YES
Takagi Sayuki YES
Miyamoto Karin YES
Uemura Akari YES

Assorted non-H!P/graduated

Mano Erina YES
Mitsui Aika NO
Kikkawa You YES
Tasaki Asahi YES
LoVendoЯ NO
-->however Tanaka Reina YES and Miyazawa Marin YES (other two NO).


Let me reiterate that I do not hate/dislike any of these girls.
I don't know how any of them act in private. This is all based on their performance and public persona.
I wish them all well and the greatest succes.
JonCC
Devotee
 
Posts: 3998
Joined: Fri Dec 30, 2011 8:23 pm
Has thanked: 2628 times
Been thanked: 1194 times
Favorite Idol: Sayashi Riho

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Rm88 » Sun Sep 29, 2013 4:48 pm

Berryz Koubou:
1- Momoko
2- Chinami
3- Captain
4- Yurina
5- Maasa
6- Risako
7- Miyabi

Pretty standard, no big changes. Risako unusally low, though, she's not part of the "we're all tied for third place" group along with Captain and Yurina, and fell below Maasa. This doesn't mean a ton since it's Berryz :lol: There's really no bad place in that list for me.

Morning Musume:
1- Sayumi -- Eventually came back to number one after the new member hype cooled down. It definitely took a while :lol:
2- Haruka -- Suddenly in second place. Rather surprising, I never disliked her but she was definitely below Ayumi, Riho and Haruna before.
3- Ayumi -- As someone who thinks Chinami is the second best idol walking on Earth, I'm not sure why Ayumi's weak singing made such an impact on me. I mean, that's Sayumi in number one in this list, lol.
4- Riho -- Such a balanced, complete idol, it's pretty hard not to like her.
5- Haruna -- What is this? Haruna was number one not that long ago. Oh well, I still like her a lot.
6- Eripon -- She's a really cool member, and one of the absolute biggest comebacks anyone has ever made in my ranking :lol: I wasn't very happy about her getting in the group initially.
7- Kanon -- She's okay, I like her.
8- Mizuki -- Same as above.
9- Masaki -- Same as above.
10- Sakura -- I'm not sure what's preventing me from warming up to her, it's like I still feel she's a bit out of place in the group. Despite knowing that's not the case. Weird.

S/mileage:
1- Kanana -- In the sad, dark world that will be H!P for me once Momoko and Chinami are not there anymore, Kanana will be there to keep my fandom alive.
2- Dawa -- Perfect leader Dawa, too awesome.
3- Takechan -- Honestly not that far from Dawa.
4- Kanon -- I think she's so underrated. She's cute, talented and charismatic. Maybe she did that to her hair to get our attention? :lol:
5- Meimi -- Meimi is a Riho-like ace.
6- Rina -- I like Rina a lot, but she seems to be stuck in background member mode.

Juice=Juice:
1- Akari -- Yurina part two is fantastic, instant favorite.
2- Karin -- Big comeback, has to be because of Jurin. Also an ace.
3- Tomoko -- Incredibly solid idol, adds a lot to the group.
4- Sayuki -- What. I seriously though she'd never leave last place :lol: I like her singing a lot and she happens to be a Momochi fan. Can't go wrong with her.
5- Yuka -- My initial favorite is currently in 5th place. I like her just as much as before, she was just surpassed by the rest.
User avatar
Rm88
Member
 
Posts: 2205
Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 9:29 am
Has thanked: 45 times
Been thanked: 130 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Starra » Wed Oct 02, 2013 11:56 am

MM。voice ranking by generation:
Spoiler: show
1st:
1. Yuuko
2. Asuka
3. Kaori
4. Aya
5. Nacchi

2nd/3rd:
1. Kei
2. Maki
3. Sayaka
4. Mari

4th:
1. Kago
2. Rika
3. Yossy
4. Tsuji

5th:
1. Risa
2. Konno
3. Ai
4. Makoto

6th:
1. Miki
2. Eri
3. Sayumi
4. Reina

7th/8th:
1. Junjun
2. Aika
3. Koharu
4. Linlin

9th:
1. Riho
2. Zukki
3. Mizuki
4. Erina

10th/11th:
1. Sakura
2. Ayumi
3. Haruka
4. Masaki
5. Haruna


Berikyuu:
1. Momoko
2. Mai
3. Risako
4. Maasa
5. Airi
6. Maimi
7. Miyabi
8. Saki
9. Yurina
10. Nacky
11. Chisato
12. Chinami

S/mileage:
1. Meimi
2. Akari
3. Kana
4. Kanon
5. Rina
6. Ayaka

Juice=Juice:
1. Tomoko
2. Karin
3. Akari
4. Yuka
5. Sayuki
中澤裕子紺野あさ美萩原舞金澤朋子山﨑愛生梁川奈々美加賀楓須藤茉麻田村芽実平井美葉清野桃々姫福田真琳松本わかな岸本ゆめの・松原ユリヤ♡
User avatar
Starra
Prophet
 
Posts: 8281
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 11:34 am
Location: New Zealand
Has thanked: 435 times
Been thanked: 1472 times
Favorite Idol: Nakazawa Yuuko

PreviousNext

Return to Hello! Project

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], minahikki and 38 guests