H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[Amped]

new generation H!P - Mixi as of 6/24 since 4/1

+269 Ishida Ayumi (633→902)　娘10
+256 Kudou (1094→1350)　娘10
+215 Riho (2150→2365)　娘9
+171 Masaki (609→780)　娘10
+142 Ikuta Erina (1296→1438)　娘9
+133 Mizuki (1409→1542)　娘9
+133 Iikubo Haruna (602→735)　娘10
+82 Zukki (1159→1241)　娘9
+29 Takechan (473→502)　スマ2
+23 Kana (348→371)　スマ2
+21 Dawa (2161→2182)　スマ1
+18 Katsuta (298→316)　スマ2
+8 Meimei (357→365)　スマ2
-9 Kanon (2133→2124)　スマ1

[iceymoon]

new generation H!P - Mixi as of 6/24 since 4/1

+269 Ishida Ayumi (633→902)　娘10
+256 Kudou (1094→1350)　娘10
+215 Riho (2150→2365)　娘9
+171 Masaki (609→780)　娘10
+142 Ikuta Erina (1296→1438)　娘9
+133 Mizuki (1409→1542)　娘9
+133 Iikubo Haruna (602→735)　娘10
+82 Zukki (1159→1241)　娘9
+29 Takechan (473→502)　スマ2
+23 Kana (348→371)　スマ2
+21 Dawa (2161→2182)　スマ1
+18 Katsuta (298→316)　スマ2
+8 Meimei (357→365)　スマ2
-9 Kanon (2133→2124)　スマ1

in order by number (took out Dawa & Kanyon cuz they're not newbies):
+215 Riho (2150→2365)　娘9
+133 Mizuki (1409→1542)　娘9
+142 Ikuta Erina (1296→1438)　娘9
+256 Kudou (1094→1350)　娘10
+82 Zukki (1159→1241)　娘9
+269 Ishida Ayumi (633→902)　娘10
+171 Masaki (609→780)　娘10
+133 Iikubo Haruna (602→735)　娘10
+29 Takechan (473→502)　スマ2
+23 Kana (348→371)　スマ2
+8 Meimei (357→365)　スマ2
+18 Katsuta (298→316)　スマ2

[Starra]

Love - Like a lot - Like - Meh - Not a fan

MM。by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Morning Coffee→Memory Seishun no Hikari
1. Nakazawa Yuuko
2. Ishiguro Aya
3. Iida Kaori
4. Fukuda Asuka
5. Yasuda Kei
6. Abe Natsumi
7. Ichii Sayaka
8. Yaguchi Mari

Manatsu no Kousen→Furusato:
1. Nakazawa Yuuko
2. Ishiguro Aya
3. Iida Kaori
4. Yasuda Kei
5. Abe Natsumi
6. Ichii Sayaka
7. Yaguchi Mari

LOVE Machine:
1. Nakazawa Yuuko
2. Gotou Maki
3. Ishiguro Aya
4. Iida Kaori
5. Yasuda Kei
6. Abe Natsumi
7. Ichii Sayaka
8. Yaguchi Mari

Happy Summer Wedding:
1. Nakazawa Yuuko
2. Gotou Maki
3. Iida Kaori
4. Ishikawa Rika
5. Yasuda Kei
6. Abe Natsumi
7. Yoshizawa Hitomi
8. Ichii Sayaka
9. Kago Ai
10. Yaguchi Mari
11. Tsuji Nozomi

I WISH→Renai Revolution 21:
1. Nakazawa Yuuko
2. Gotou Maki
3. Iida Kaori
4. Ishikawa Rika
5. Yasuda Kei
6. Abe Natsumi
7. Yoshizawa Hitomi
8. Kago Ai
9. Yaguchi Mari
10. Tsuji Nozomi

The☆Peace!:
1. Gotou Maki
2. Iida Kaori
3. Ishikawa Rika
4. Yasuda Kei
5. Abe Natsumi
6. Yoshizawa Hitomi
7. Kago Ai
8. Yaguchi Mari
9. Tsuji Nozomi

Mr. Moonlight〜Ai no Big Band〜→Do it! Now:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Gotou Maki
4. Iida Kaori
5. Takahashi Ai
6. Ishikawa Rika
7. Yasuda Kei
8. Abe Natsumi
9. Ogawa Makoto
10. Yoshizawa Hitomi
11. Kago Ai
12. Yaguchi Mari
13. Tsuji Nozomi

Koko ni Iru zee!→AS FOR ONE DAY:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Iida Kaori
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Ishikawa Rika
6. Yasuda Kei
7. Abe Natsumi
8. Ogawa Makoto
9. Yoshizawa Hitomi
10. Kago Ai
11. Yaguchi Mari
12. Tsuji Nozomi

Shabondama→Ai Araba IT'S ALL RIGHT:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Iida Kaori
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Ishikawa Rika
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Abe Natsumi
9. Fujimoto Miki
10. Ogawa Makoto
11. Yoshizawa Hitomi
12. Kago Ai
13. Kamei Eri
14. Yaguchi Mari
15. Tsuji Nozomi

Roman〜MY DEAR BOY〜:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Iida Kaori
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Ishikawa Rika
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Fujimoto Miki
9. Ogawa Makoto
10. Yoshizawa Hitomi
11. Kago Ai
12. Kamei Eri
13. Yaguchi Mari
14. Tsuji Nozomi

Joshi Kashimashi Monogatari→THE Manpower!!!
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Iida Kaori
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Ishikawa Rika
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Fujimoto Miki
9. Ogawa Makoto
10. Yoshizawa Hitomi
11. Kamei Eri
12. Yaguchi Mari

Osaka Koi no Uta:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Takahashi Ai
4. Ishikawa Rika
5. Tanaka Reina
6. Michishige Sayumi
7. Fujimoto Miki
8. Ogawa Makoto
9. Yoshizawa Hitomi
10. Kamei Eri
11. Yaguchi Mari

Iroppoi Jirettai→Ambitious! Yashinteki de Ii jan:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Kusumi Koharu
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Tanaka Reina
6. Michishige Sayumi
7. Fujimoto Miki
8. Ogawa Makoto
9. Yoshizawa Hitomi
10. Kamei Eri

Aruiteru:
1. Niigaki Risa
2. Kusumi Koharu
3. Takahashi Ai
4. Tanaka Reina
5. Michishige Sayumi
6. Fujimoto Miki
7. Yoshizawa Hitomi
8. Kamei Eri

Egao YES Nude→Kanashimi Twilight:
1. Niigaki Risa
2. Mitsui Aika
3. Kusumi Koharu
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Tanaka Reina
6. Michishige Sayumi
7. Fujimoto Miki
8. Yoshizawa Hitomi
9. Kamei Eri

Onna ni Sachi Are→Kimgaure Princess:
1. Niigaki Risa
2. Mitsui Aika
3. Kusumi Koharu
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Junjun
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Linlin
8. Michishige Sayumi
9. Kamei Eri

Onna ga Medatte Naze Ikenai→Onna to Otoko no Lullaby Game
1. Niigaki Risa
2. Mitsui Aika
3. Takahashi Ai
4. Junjun
5. Tanaka Reina
6. Linlin
7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Kamei Eri

Maji de Sukasuka!→Kono Chikyuu no Heiwa wo Honki de Negatterun da yo! / Kare to Issho ni Omise ga Shitai!:
1. Sayashi Riho
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Mitsui Aika
4. Takahashi Ai
5. Tanaka Reina
6. Suzuki Kanon
7. Michishige Sayumi
8. Ikuta Erina
9. Fukumura Mizuki

Pyocopyoco Ultra→Renai Hunter:
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Sayashi Riho
3. Niigaki Risa
4. Mitsui Aika
5. Iikubo Haruna
6. Tanaka Reina
7. Suzuki Kanon
8. Michishige Sayumi
9. Ikuta Erina
10. Fukumura Mizuki
11. Satou Masaki
12. Kudou Haruka

One・Two・Three / The Matenrou Show→current:
1. Ishida Ayumi
2. Sayashi Riho
3. Iikubo Haruna
4. Tanaka Reina
5. Suzuki Kanon
6. Michishige Sayumi
7. Ikuta Erina
8. Fukumura Mizuki
9. Satou Masaki
10. Kudou Haruka

Berryz by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Anata Nashi de wa Ikite Yukenai→21ji Made no Cinderella:
1. Sudou Maasa
2. Tsugunaga Momoko
3. Sugaya Risako
4. Ishimura Maiha
5. Kumai Yurina
6. Tokunaga Chinami
7. Shimizu Saki
8. Natsuyaki Miyabi

Gag 100kaibun Aishite Kudasai→current:
1. Sudou Maasa
2. Tsugunaga Momoko
3. Sugaya Risako
4. Kumai Yurina
5. Tokunaga Chinami
6. Shimizu Saki
7. Natsuyaki Miyabi

℃-ute by lineups:

Spoiler: show

H!P Kids era:
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Nakajima Saki
3. Yajima Maimi
4. Suzuki Airi
5. Umeda Erika
6. Okai Chisato
7. Murakami Megumi

Massara Blue Jeans→Wakkyanai (Z):
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Nakajima Saki
3. Yajima Maimi
4. Suzuki Airi
5. Umeda Erika
6. Arihara Kanna
7. Okai Chisato
8. Murakami Megumi

Sakura Chirari→FOREVER LOVE:
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Nakajima Saki
3. Yajima Maimi
4. Suzuki Airi
5. Umeda Erika
6. Arihara Kanna
7. Okai Chisato

Bye Bye Bye!→EVERYDAY Zekkouchou!!:
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Nakajima Saki
3. Yajima Maimi
4. Suzuki Airi
5. Umeda Erika
6. Okai Chisato

SHOCK!→current:
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Nakajima Saki
3. Yajima Maimi
4. Suzuki Airi
5. Okai Chisato

S/mileage by lineups:

Spoiler: show

aMa no Jaku→Uchouten LOVE:
1. Fukuda Kanon
2. Wada Ayaka
3. Maeda Yuuka
4. Ogawa Saki

Tachiagirl:
1. Tamura Meimi
2. Fukuda Kanon
3. Wada Ayaka
4. Kosuga Fuyuka
5. Nakanishi Kana
6. Katsuta Rina
7. Takeuchi Akari
8. Maeda Yuuka

Please Miniskirt Postwoman!:
1. Tamura Meimi
2. Fukuda Kanon
3. Wada Ayaka
4. Nakanishi Kana
5. Katsuta Rina
6. Takeuchi Akari
7. Maeda Yuuka

Choto Mate Kudasai!→current:
1. Tamura Meimi
2. Fukuda Kanon
3. Wada Ayaka
4. Nakanishi Kana
5. Katsuta Rina
6. Takeuchi Akari

Melon Kinenbi:
1. Saitou Hitomi
2. Murata Megumi
3. Ootani Masae
4. Shibata Ayumi

W:
1. Kago Ai
2. Tsuji Nozomi

Viyuden:
1. Ishikawa Rika
2. Miyoshi Erika
3. Okada Yui

GAM:
1. Fujimoto Miki
2. Matsuura Aya

Minimoni。/Shin Minimoni。 by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Minimoni。Jankenpyon! / Haru Natsu Aki Fuyu Daisukki!→Minihams no Kekkon Song
1. Mika
2. Kago Ai
3. Yaguchi Mari
4. Tsuji Nozomi

Rock 'n' Roll Kenchoushozaichi〜Oboechai na Series〜→Lucky Cha Cha Cha!:
1. Takahashi Ai
2. Mika
3. Kago Ai
4. Tsuji Nozomi

Shin Minimoni。:
1. Miyamoto Karin
2. Fukuda Kanon
3. Linlin
4. Takeuchi Akari

Tanpopo/Tanpopo♯ by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Last Kiss→Seinaru Kane ga Hibiku Yoru:
1. Ishiguro Aya
2. Iida Kaori
3. Yaguchi Mari

Otome Pasta ni Kandou→Oujisama to Yuki no Yoru:
1. Ishiguro Aya
2. Iida Kaori
3. Ishikawa Rika
4. Yaguchi Mari

BE HAPPY Koi no Yajirobee:
1. Konno Asami
2. Niigaki Risa
3. Ishikawa Rika
4. Shibata Ayumi

Tanpopo♯:
1. Mitsui Aika
2. Kumai Yurina
3. Kamei Eri
4. Okai Chisato

Pucchimoni / PucchimoniⅤ by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Chokotto LOVE:
1. Gotou Maki
2. Yoshizawa Hitomi
3. Ichii Sayaka

Seishun Jidai 1.2.3!→Pittari Shitai X'mas!:
1. Gotou Maki
2. Yasuda Kei
3. Yoshizawa Hitomi

WOW WOW WOW:
1. Ayaka
2. Ogawa Makoto
3. Yoshizawa Hitomi

PucchimoniⅤ:
1. Hagiwara Mai
2. Mano Erina
3. Nakajima Saki

Country Musume。by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Futari no Hokkaido:
1. Rinne
2. Yanagihara Hiromi
3. Kobayashi Azusa

Yukigeshiki→Hokkaido Shalala:
1. Rinne

Koi ga Suteki na Kisetsu:
1. Rinne
2. Asami

Hajimete no Happy Birthday!→Koibito wa Kokoro no Ouendan:
1. Ishikawa Rika
2. Rinne
3. Asami

Iroppoi Onna〜SEXY BABY〜:
1. Ishikawa Rika
2. Rinne
3. Asami
4. Satoda Mai

BYE BYE Saigo no Yoru:
1. Ishikawa Rika
2. Asami
3. Satoda Mai

Uwaki na Honey Pie→Shining Itoshiki Anata:
1. Konno Asami
2. Fujimoto Miki
3. Miuna
4. Asami
5. Satoda Mai

Country Musume。Daizenshuu ②:
1. Miuna
2. Asami
3. Satoda Mai

Post-Daizenshuu ②:
1. Satoda Mai

Taiyou to Ciscomoon / T&C Bomber by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Tsuki to Taiyou→Magic of Love ; DON'T STOP Renaichuu→HEY! Mahiru no Shinkirou:
1. Inaba Atsuko
2. Honda Ruru
3. Kominato Miwa
4. Shinoda Miho

Marui Taiyou -winter ver.-:
1. Inaba Atsuko
2. Honda Ruru
3. Shinoda Miho

Coconuts Musume。by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Halation Summer→DANCE&CHANCE:
1. Danielle
2. Ayaka
3. April
4. Chelsea
5. Mika

Tokonatsu Musume→Watashi mo『I LOVE YOU』:
1. Danielle
2. Lehua
3. Ayaka
4. Mika

Jounetsu Yuki Miraisen:
1. Lehua
2. Ayaka
3. Mika

1. Ayaka
2. Mika

1. Ayaka

Shekidol by lineups:

Spoiler: show

Kokoro no Pheromone:
1. Kitagami Ami
2. Ooki Ibuki

Tetteiteki Unmei→Zentaiteki ni Daisuki desu。:
1. Kitagami Ami
2. Ooki Ibuki
3. Suenaga Mami

Ai wa Muteki〜Hatachi no Yoru no Chikai〜:
1. Kitagami Ami
2. Suenaga Mami
3. Arai Saki

[AyuHikaru]

new generation H!P - Mixi as of 6/24 since 4/1

+269 Ishida Ayumi (633→902)　娘10
+256 Kudou (1094→1350)　娘10
+215 Riho (2150→2365)　娘9
+171 Masaki (609→780)　娘10
+142 Ikuta Erina (1296→1438)　娘9
+133 Mizuki (1409→1542)　娘9
+133 Iikubo Haruna (602→735)　娘10
+82 Zukki (1159→1241)　娘9
+29 Takechan (473→502)　スマ2
+23 Kana (348→371)　スマ2
+21 Dawa (2161→2182)　スマ1
+18 Katsuta (298→316)　スマ2
+8 Meimei (357→365)　スマ2
-9 Kanon (2133→2124)　スマ1

in order by number (took out Dawa & Kanyon cuz they're not newbies):
+215 Riho (2150→2365)　娘9
+133 Mizuki (1409→1542)　娘9
+142 Ikuta Erina (1296→1438)　娘9
+256 Kudou (1094→1350)　娘10
+82 Zukki (1159→1241)　娘9
+269 Ishida Ayumi (633→902)　娘10
+171 Masaki (609→780)　娘10
+133 Iikubo Haruna (602→735)　娘10
+29 Takechan (473→502)　スマ2
+23 Kana (348→371)　スマ2
+8 Meimei (357→365)　スマ2
+18 Katsuta (298→316)　スマ2

You know, I'm actually surprised Meimi isn't more popular, considering her push and the fact foreign fans seem to love her.

[Panic Nancy]

It's odd.

[Zunu]

The difference between Meimi and the other Smileage newbs is not really much more than a rounding error.
And I always wonder how people conclude how many "foreign fans seem to love" X? Based on the most strident and annoying fans on H!O and other popular sites?

[AyuHikaru]

Generally on a Facebook idol goods buying site,when splitting S/mileage, Meimi is always snatched up first, followed by Dawa and Kanon. I basically go by what people are buying. Meimi, Ayumi, Risako, and Riho are the big names in selling/buying atm. C-ute hardly ever gets split, which is odd... I'm starting to believe C-ute is more popular as a UNIT than as individual idols (save for Airi, of course)

[iceymoon]

but that doesn't show general popularity, only popularity of members among 1) the people in the FB group, 2) the people in the FB group who have enough money, and 3) the people in the FB group who have enough money and are interested in the items put up for sale/split.

based on observations/experience, i'd say S/mileage is popular in that it has more casual/non H!P fans. which means it doesn't necessarily translate to sales outside of CD's, and so that's what's reflecting on Mixi. Meimi is probably more popular than those figures show, if you count the people that don't subscribe to their favorite idols on Mixi.

i still think S/mileage is not that popular in general among H!P fans though.. when i was trying to trade pin-ups, it's so much harder to trade S/mileage for other groups. their popularity doesn't compare to other groups (yet), though i think at least Meimi should be comparable to the less popular MM girls.

[Starra]

Shuffle songs:

Spoiler: show

1. Akai Nikkichou
2. Aoi Sports Cat no Otoko (I'm not fixing the typo.)
3. Shiawase Beam! Suki Suki Beam!
4. ALL FOR ONE & ONE FOR ALL!
5. Kiiroi Osora de BOOM BOM BOOM
6. Yoku Aru Oyako no Serenade
7. Shiawase Desu ka?
8. Inshouha Renoir no You ni
9. BE ALL RIGHT!
10. Sankaku Kankei
11. Onna, Kanashii, Otona
12. Dancing! Natsu Matsuri
13. GET UP! RAPPER
14. Hitoshirezu Mune wo Kanaderu Yoru no Aki
15. Chu! Natsu Party
16. Suki ni Naccha Ikenai Hito
17. Summer Reggae! Rainbow
18. Hello! no Theme
19. Kowarenai Ai ga Hoshii no
20. Shiawase Kyouryuu Ondo
21. OH! BE MY FRIEND
22. HELLO! Mata Aou ne

Shuffle groups (based off of how many members I like):

Spoiler: show

1. H.P. All Stars
2. Akagumi 4
3. Aoiro 7
4. Kiiro 5
5. Puripuri Pink
6. 11WATER
7. 7nin Matsuri
8. Odoru 11
9. 7AIR
10. 10nin Matsuri
11. SALT5
12. Happy 7
13. Sexy 8
14. Elegies
15. Sannin Matsuri
16. Sexy Otona Jan

[iceymoon]

Shuffles by year (overall):
1. 2005
2. 2003
3. 2004
4. 2000
5. 2001
6. 2002

2001 has 3nin Matsuri which makes me think it should be higher, but then i think of 7nin Matsuri, Summer Reggae Rainbow is one of the worst H!P songs.. if it wasn't for Gocchin i might hate it. and 10nin Matsuri is fun, so i struggled whether i should put it above 2000.. but overall i think Akai Nikkichou holds its own by itself above all the Matsuri songs.

2002 i'm not fond of in general except for Odoru 11, and it's only about as good as 10nin Matsuri.

By group (based on song):
1. Sexy Otonajan
2. SALT 5
3. Akagumi 4
4. 3nin Matsuri
5. Elegies
6. 11WATER
7. H.P. ALL STARS
8. Odoru 11
9. 10nin Matsuri
10. Sexy 8
11. Kiiro 5
12. 7AIR
13. Aoiro 7
14. Happy 7
15. PuriPuri Pink
16. 7nin Matsuri

BEST omg!! - LOVE - like a lot - like - ok - eh

this explains why i had trouble ranking by year. my top 4 all came from different years, and a 5th year (ALL STARS year) isn't far behind. also my bottom 5 all came from different years.