H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Morning Musume。'14, Berryz Kobo, ℃-ute, S/mileage, Juice=Juice, Hello!Project, TNX, and more

Moderator: Moh

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby iceymoon » Sat Oct 29, 2011 4:31 am

i liked Yossie better when she was MM, but i wouldn't want to move her up in my current list for that. XD then i'd move KonKon up a bunch too.. it's hard to hold on to how i felt about them if i hardly even remember what that feels like anymore.
User avatar
iceymoon
Member
 
Posts: 2251
Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 3:01 am
Has thanked: 1122 times
Been thanked: 155 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby boinsie » Sat Oct 29, 2011 4:34 am

Rm88 wrote:- There's not one single Maki song I like (pre-Glass no Pumps, after, and post-H!P).
Not even Genshoku Gal? Here, I'll embed the StepMania fan-version, to assist in gamer cred. :hehe:

[youtube]nAZVTYRRX28[/youtube]
User avatar
boinsie
Guru
 
Posts: 7167
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2007 11:39 am
Location: Rogue Valley, OR
Has thanked: 2874 times
Been thanked: 1451 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Mirai » Sat Oct 29, 2011 4:48 am

I'll play too XD

Love - Really Like - Like - Okay - Meh

1st: Yuuko, Aya, Kaori, Nacchi, Asuka
2nd: Kei, Mari, Sayaka
3rd: Maki
4th: Rika, Yossi, Tsuji, Kago
5th: Ai, Konno, Makoto, Risa
6th: Miki, Eri, Sayumi, Reina
7th: Koharu
8th: Aika, JunJun, LinLin
9th: Mizuki, Erina, Riho, Kanon
10th: Haruna, Ayumi, Masaki, Haruka

I grew to like Koharu in the end, but I'll still put "meh" for her. Ai is my top favorite forever and ever.
User avatar
Mirai
Minion
 
Posts: 1084
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2011 3:20 am
Location: California
Has thanked: 400 times
Been thanked: 49 times
Favorite Idol: Ai Takahashi

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Starra » Sat Oct 29, 2011 8:09 am

Love to death - Like - Meh - Dislike - Can't stand

-Yuuko
-Aya
-Kaori
-Natsumi
-Asuka
-Kei
-Mari
-Sayaka
-Maki
-Rika
-Yossy
-Tsuji
-Kago
-Ai
-Konno
-Makoto
-Risa
-Miki
-Eri
-Sayumi
-Reina
-Koharu
-Aika
-Junjun
-Linlin
-Mizuki
-Erina
-Riho
-Kanon
-Haruna
-Ayumi
-Masaki
-Kuduu

The "can't stand" is a bit of an exaggeration. It basically means that I would prefer it if the girls weren't around, but it doesn't mean I have anything against them personally. I'm just not a fan AT ALL and I really don't enjoy them.
中澤裕子紺野あさ美萩原舞金澤朋子山﨑愛生梁川奈々美加賀楓須藤茉麻田村芽実平井美葉清野桃々姫福田真琳松本わかな岸本ゆめの・松原ユリヤ♡
User avatar
Starra
Prophet
 
Posts: 8281
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 11:34 am
Location: New Zealand
Has thanked: 435 times
Been thanked: 1472 times
Favorite Idol: Nakazawa Yuuko

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Naomi » Sat Oct 29, 2011 9:45 am

Me too. XD

Love, Really Like, Okay, Meh, Dislike

1st Gen: Yuko, Aya, Kaori, Nacchi, Asuka
2nd Gen: Kei, Mari, Sayaka
3rd Gen: Maki
4th Gen: Rika, Yossie, Tsuji, Kago
5th Gen: Ai, Konkon, Makoto, Gaki
6th Gen: Miki, Eri, Sayumi, Reina
7th Gen: Koharu
8th Gen: Aika, Junjun, Linlin
9th Gen: Mizuki, Eripon, Riho, Kanon
10th Gen: Haruna, Ayumi, Masaki, Haruka

I like more than I thought. xD
User avatar
Naomi
Senior Initiate
 
Posts: 136
Joined: Wed Oct 22, 2008 7:45 am
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 1 time
Favorite Idol: Yossie, Ayumi

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby marippeTakacrotchi » Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:10 am

OK, this is fun.

Love - Really Like- Like -Okay - Meh - Dislike

1st: Yuuko, Aya, Kaori, Nacchi, Asuka
2nd: Kei, Mari, Sayaka
3rd: Maki
4th: Rika, Yossi, Tsuji, Kago
5th: Ai, Konno, Makoto, Risa
6th: Miki, Eri, Sayumi, Reina
7th: Koharu
8th: Aika, JunJun, LinLin
9th: Mizuki, Erina, Riho, Kanon
10th: Haruna, Ayumi, Masaki, Haruka

These have changed around a bit. Some I wavered on over the years. For example, when 5th gen first joined, I really hated Ai and Risa and really liked Makoto and Asami. Some I just really can't form an opinion on. Like Mizuki because she's wallpaper and JunJun and LinLin because I fell out of H!P fandom around that time and missed their glory days. Some of them I liked better when they graduated like Nacchi and Hitomi.
User avatar
marippeTakacrotchi
Senior Initiate
 
Posts: 93
Joined: Thu Oct 30, 2008 2:28 am
Location: Raleigh, NC
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 0 time

For colorblind lurkers! :)

Postby Zunu » Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:35 am

A+ = Basically Perfect
A = Awesome
B = I like this girl but don't LOVE her
C = Some good moments, some bad moments
F = Basically equivalent to Starra's "can't stand."
Q = Haven't formed a strong opinion about yet.

A+: Kaori / A: Ayappe / B: Asuka / C: Yuuko, Nacchi
B: Kei, Sayaka / C: Mari
C: Maki
A: Kago / B: Rika, Tsuji / F: Yossi
A+: Aichan / C: Risa, Makoto / F: Konno
A+: Eri, Sayumi / A: Reina / C: Miki
A: Koharu
B: Junjun / C: Aika / F: Linlin
A: Kanon / B: Mizuki / C: Erina / Q: Riho
B: Haruka / Q: Ayumi, Haruna, Masaki
tending to put ~ on song titles since 2002
User avatar
Zunu
Pantaloon
 
Posts: 7935
Joined: Tue May 06, 2008 6:09 am
Location: miyaa planet
Has thanked: 3845 times
Been thanked: 2617 times
Favorite Idol: 能登有沙

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Starra » Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:54 am

With the rest of Mobekimasu (+ graduates)...

Love to death - Like - Meh - Dislike - Can't stand

Spoiler: show
-Shimizu
-Momoko
-Chinami
-Maasa
-Maiha
-Miyabi
-Yurina
-Risako

-Erika
-Maimi
-Nacky
-Megumi
-Airi
-Chisato
-Mai
-Kanna

-Mano

-Ayaka
-Yuuka
-Kanon
-Sakitty
-Takechan
-Rina
-Kana
-Fuyuka
-Meimi



Eggs:
Spoiler: show
-Korenaga Miki
-Morozuka Kanami
-Oose Kaede
-Sengoku Minami
-Hashimoto Aina
-Akiyama Yurika
-Okada Robin Shouko
-Gotou Yuki
-Saho Akari
-Kikkawa You
-Tanabe Nanami
-Hamaura Ayano
-Taguchi Natsumi
-Kawashima Miyuki
-Noto Arisa
-Aoki Erina
-Tanaka Anri
-Sawada Yuri
-Mutou Mika
-Hashida Mirei
-Furukawa Konatsu
-Ooyanagi Maho
-Sainen Mia
-Mori Saki
-Yutoku Ayumi
-Kitahara Sayaka
-Okai Asuna
-Sekine Azusa
-Arai Manami
-Ogura Manami
-Komine Momoka
-Maeda Irori
-Kaneko Rie
-Miyamoto Karin
-Sezaki Azusa
-Satou Ayano
-Hirano Tomomi
-Takagi Sayuki
-Kizawa Runa
-Nagasawa Wakana
-Jang Dayon
-Yoshihashi Kurumi
-Ootsuka Aina
-Mogi Minami
-Ogawa Rena


Coconuts Musume。:
Spoiler: show
-Ayaka
-Chelsea
-April
-Danielle
-Mika
-Lehua


Country Musume。:
Spoiler: show
-Azusa
-Hiromi
-Rinne
-Asami
-Satoda
-Miuna


Taiyou to Ciscomoon:
Spoiler: show
-Miho
-Inaba
-Miwa
-Ruru


Ice Creamusume。/ Da Xiao Jie:
Spoiler: show
-Shenshen
-Anchii
-Peipei
-Youko
-Reirei
-Guuchan
-Frances
-Aiko


Melon Kinenbi:
Spoiler: show
-Muracchi
-Boss
-Masae
-Ayumi


Shekidol:
Spoiler: show
-Ami
-Ibuki
-Mami
-Saki


Viyuden:
Spoiler: show
-Yui
-Erika


SI☆NA:
Spoiler: show
-Manami
-Asami
-Ai
-Nana


Soloists:
Spoiler: show
-Heike
-Yuki
-Aya
-Ishii
-Miyoshi
-Simmin
中澤裕子紺野あさ美萩原舞金澤朋子山﨑愛生梁川奈々美加賀楓須藤茉麻田村芽実平井美葉清野桃々姫福田真琳松本わかな岸本ゆめの・松原ユリヤ♡
User avatar
Starra
Prophet
 
Posts: 8281
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2008 11:34 am
Location: New Zealand
Has thanked: 435 times
Been thanked: 1472 times
Favorite Idol: Nakazawa Yuuko

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Chatin » Sat Oct 29, 2011 12:10 pm

Love, Like, Okay, Meh, Dislike

1st Gen: Yuko, Aya, Kaori, Nacchi, Asuka
2nd Gen: Kei, Mari, Sayaka
3rd Gen: Maki
4th Gen: Rika, Yossie, Tsuji, Kago
5th Gen: Ai, Konkon, Makoto, Gaki**
6th Gen: Miki, Eri, Sayumi, Reina
7th Gen: Koharu
8th Gen: Aika, Junjun, Linlin
9th Gen: Mizuki, Eripon, Riho, Kanon
10th Gen: Haruna, Ayumi, Masaki, Haruka

**Risa I find too difficult to rate because I am literally completely hot or completely cold on her from occasion to occasion. Get it under control, Gakisan.

Yuko is the only musume I currently, actively dislike. Konkon, Tsuji, and Aika have slipped out of dislike territory into meh. Reina has recently bumped herself up to Love. My H!P alltime least favorite has to be Satoda Mai, though.
User avatar
Chatin
Minion
 
Posts: 1152
Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2008 5:12 am
Location: I think we're alone now...
Has thanked: 42 times
Been thanked: 104 times

Re: H!P/etc Ranking Thread

Postby Bakajo Nono » Sat Oct 29, 2011 12:50 pm

Ooh fun.

Love! Like! Okay Meh Dislike
1st Gen: Yuko Kaori Nacchi Asuka Aya
2nd Gen: Mari Sayaka Kei
3rd Gen: Maki
4th Gen: Yossie Rika Aibon Nono
5th Gen: Ai-chan Risa Mako-chan Konkon
6th Gen: :heart: :love: Eri :love: :heart: Miki Sayumi Reina
7th Gen: Koharu
8th Gen: Aika Linlin Junjun
9th Gen: Fuku-chan (twin!) Eripon Zukki Riho (sometimes dislike, but I like her dancing, but we don't see much of it so idk idk)

I think they're all lovely girls. The okay/meh/dislike are, for the most part, based on vocal/dancing quality in my opinion. But if I love their personality (Koharu xD) then I at least ~like~ them over all.

Current Morning Musume ranking +10gen - Ai-chan ;.;
1. GAAAAKIIIIII <3 (plzplzplzdon'tleaveme)
2. REINAAAAAA
3. Uhhh Fuku-chan!
4. Zukki
5. Eripon
6. Sayumi
7. Riho
8. Aika
9. Haruka ?
10. Ayumi ?
11. Haruna ?
12. Masaki ?
Last edited by Bakajo Nono on Sat Oct 29, 2011 1:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Bakajo Nono
Acolyte
 
Posts: 557
Joined: Fri Jul 22, 2011 4:34 am
Location: America's Most Trusted News Team.
Has thanked: 28 times
Been thanked: 21 times
Favorite Idol: Eri Kamei

PreviousNext

Return to Hello! Project

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 23 guests