Celedam wrote:Then I didn't explain it properly…?
Not at all! I wasn't paying particularly close attention, is all. I was mildly familiar with Critical Role from having tried to watch* an episode or two back when it was on the VRV streaming service, and the boredom I associated with the name brand (sorry!) sort of disincentivized me to follow the details about the project. From there I probably just filled in the blanks with my preconceptions; that's totally on me.
And I think we agree that it's good the show can be enjoyed on multiple levels. But since your glowing assessment is in part based on your higher level knowledge of the characters and campaigns, I wanted to concur, and add for the rest of us "rubes" that even on the non-knowledgeable level, it's a pretty fun show, and a solid find. By way of comparison, I also watch the Star Trek based cartoon, The Lower Decks. And while I enjoy it equally as much, I think it relies a great deal -- maybe overmuch -- on the source material for its gags, and probably loses a lot of humor to people lacking the source lore. So I wouldn't particularly recommend it to a non-"Trekkie."
*that grammar sounds a bit off to me but y'all know what I mean.