[09/28] S/mileage - 7th Single "TACHIAGAARU"

[MrMoondoggie]

If its going to be more than one coming in i'd go with Akari and Kana. I think those two are the more complete ones when it comes to being all round decent and i think Akari is strongest of the sub members when it comes to being an all rounder (personal bias aside i still feel she's got the more complete package) When it comes to Rina and Meimi they have opporsite weaknesses. Rina is a good singer but she's boring and not very confident so probably won't improve her personality quick enough to fit in and Meimi has the personality and confidence plus she has that cute little sister look that all the female fans gush over but she really doesn't have a very good singing voice. I think it could be better in time but she might benefit more from being an egg for a while instead of having the pressure of needing to improve in a short period of time where if she doesn't she'll be feeling she's dragging the group down.

That said the way things look it really seems like they'll be bringing all four of the remaining sub members in. But then when it comes to H!P i've learned to expect nothing

[Sohee]

If he brings all four, I'll be so pissed. =_=

[321BreakinOut]

My Ideal S/mileage Would be the Original Three Plus one girl (Preferably Meimi or Akari <3) But if he adds more i just don't want Rina to get in, she's just so damn boring

[Rm88]

Rina, I don't know, I think her /_\ eyes are kind of cute

Still, only Takechan please. The rest can be eggs so they don't have to kick them out.

[Sohee]

I don't think they should kick someone out either. But Rina is far too boring and behind to match S/mileage, Meimi is too bad and Kana is too inexperienced if anything. But that could also be charming as she does have a pleasant voice and there is something awkwardly cute about her. Takechan however has insanely sharp dancing skills and can hit high notes great, and would only get better if she was to be put in S/mileage. If anything Takechan is at the same level that Ayaka is on, I think. and considering how Yuuka has improved a lot, it wouldn't be a bad move to put Takechan in. It wouldn't hold the group back at all. With her, they could take on one more newbie and... imo, only Kana is appropriate. I'm fearing Tsoonk or Yamazaki doesn't think the same as me though.

Rina could go back to being a (now slightly more popular) egg and get more training, and Meimi could go there too and get better and grow and become a popular egg so that the day when she debuts in a group they'll already have a good share of fans.

[boinsie]

So, has anyone else listened to Boogie Train '11? I swear I hear Saki. Obviously not, but... who has the deep voice, then? Is that Kanon?

[Sohee]

I have. But... I don't hear Saki - and I was listening carefully cause I wanted to see if there were any sub-members in. There are none! And yes, that one sounding really amazingly great? That would be Kanon.

[boinsie]

Kanon.
But for anyone who hasn't heard it and is curious, overall it's just as bad of a rendition of Boogie Train as everyone was worried it would be. ^^;;;
They kept the original rap from 8 years ago. What the hell is that?

[Sohee]

I... liked it? ;o;

[boinsie]

Maybe some of it is to blame on the cruddy 128kbps?
But in general they don't hold the notes long though.