+Kyu wrote:If you think that way, perhaps you should have a little more faith in the group and her fans than writing them off at getting 3rd place? Especially since we haven't even heard any of the singles yet?
I mean everyone is right by saying that its going to be very unlikely for them to jump up 100k in sales. I would be excited for them to reach anywhere near 200k. 180-190 would be pretty awesome. However, I like your enthusiasm and positive attitude. If this single is SUPER AWESOME we could possibly get a huge bump in sales. We never know when that could be. All you need is one catchy song to grab the general publics attention and Morning Musume could skyrocket in sales. Can we count on it? no. But is it good to remain positive? Yes! I don't think anyone saw One Two Three selling as much as it did when it did, but it happened and we've been consistent since!
TotallyUncool wrote:I really don't think that very many people other than wota and the music press are going to care about whether it makes #3 or #1. Wota will care because they're obsessed with everything about the idol groups that matter to them, and pop-music journalists will care because they deal in trivia and superficiality. But the general (non-wota) music audience will probably be much more interested in whether or not it's a good song than in how it does on the charts. And genuine music industry insiders understand what matters and what doesn't in terms of a group's long-term success -- so for them, I think that actual chart ratings (as opposed to sales) are useful for PR, and not much else.
This builds off my last point! I find it awesome how Love Machine became super popular and pretty multiplied sales by like 10 (I don't feel like calculating

). Furusato 170,670 -> Love Machine 1,646,630
Thats an incredible sales jump. Even AKB48 started with low sales before they jumped up to selling millions easily. And you know the best part?
Love Machine was #2 on the Oricon charts!
So my point is that in the long run whether or not the song is popular is more important than the charts! This long streak of #1s did help Morning Musume get their name back out there, but the awesome songs and dance formations also are whats helping Morning Musume gain public attention again. Can't have one without the other

As long as the song is awesome and we do get a jump in sales... any jump in sales... it wont be so important where they fall on the chart. Even getting enough sales to get close to the tough competition will be pretty impressive