H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[AyuHikaru]

Looks ranking:

A Tier
1. Risako
2. Haruna
3. Maimi
4. Ayumi
5. Sayumi
6. Airi
7. Mizuki
8. Yurina - manages to squeeze into A tier

B Tier
1. Reina
2. Masaki
3. Miyabi
4. Maasa
5. Riho
6. Chinami
7. Mai
8. Chisato
9. Kanon F.
10. DAWA
11. Haruka
12. Zukki
13. Erina Mano
14. Eripon

C Tier
1. Saki Nakajima
2. Meimi Tamura
3. Aika
4. Momoko
5. Akari
6. Kana
7. Captain

F Tier
Rina

[DARC1993]

Looks ranking:

F Tier
Rina

Thats more like it!

[Parhelion69]

I'll use Rm88's as a template:


SS Tier:

1- Sayumi. Not that great a body, but the prettiest musume/idol ever.


Top Tier:

2- Maimi. She's as close to perfection as I could imagine
3- Dawa. Incredibly cute and the longest legs ever.
4- Mano. Pretty, hot body. Complete package.
5- Airi. Almost perfect, just needs some bewbs.
6- Riho. So cute already. Just keep watching her. She's gonna be a killer
7- Masaki. Incredibly cute, and the best smile.
8- Ayumi. Really pretty, but too thin. It can change though
9- Mizuki. Gives a princess aura, and has a killer body.

High Tier:

10- Miyabi. Best legs in H!P
11- Nakki. Hot, hot, hot!
12- Kanyon. Hot! And cute!
13- Yurina. Beautiful, but her torso seems a bit weird at times.

Mid Tier:
14- Haruna. Really pretty, but way too skinny
15- Eripon. Very pretty and each time she's losing that awkward look.
16- Reina. Really pretty but has a child's body
17- Captain . Is much prettier now than some years ago
18- Haruka
19- Mai
20- Risako. Was much prettier (and hotter) some years ago. Still a pretty face though.
21- Momoko. Nice butt, but her face is just ok.
22- Meimi
23- Takechan. Weird face and a bit too short (thick legs)
24- Kana. Great legs, but she looks too awkward still
25- Chisato. Too short so her body looks a bit weird when she's not on diet.
26- Chinami. Long, but thin legs. Her face is ok


Low Tier:

27- Maasa.
28- Rina. (great legs though)
29- Zukki.

[Chibs]

kumai's torso is weird? never noticed that...also i never understood the thing about long legs, i prefer thunderthighs myself.

[Sohee]

I'll never understand what someone means when they say that Zukki is ugly. Awkward? Sure. Chubby? Sure, whatever. Ugly? The girl might not be stunningly pretty or whatever now, but she definitely will be when she's 16-17 or something, you can already see it. Her showa-face automatically makes her one of the most (to be) beautiful girls in H!P rn to me. @.@

[Zunu]

P69, I agree with a great many of those assessments, although maybe not in that particular order. Miyalegs = But Zukki? I don't get the hate. I mean, I understand, she's chubby and that is kind of an auto-disqualify for people. But to me, even despite that, she's super-adorable. So genki and bright-eyed, who can resist?

[Panic Nancy]

I wasn't going to do a full ranking because it feels kind of mean, but I just feel like saying how I feel about everybody's looks. I think everybody in current H!P is attractive in some way. Not going to do tiers.

1. Michishige Sayumi: Flawless.
2. Yajima Maimi: Flawless. I used to think she was kind of boring-looking, but now I just think she's amazing.
3. Kumai Yurina: Gorgeous.
4. Fukumura Mizuki: Gorgeous.
5. Sugaya Risako: If she were a little thinner and her make-up/styling was different (she looks too washed out most of the time), she would absolutely be number one. As she is, she’s still very, very beautiful. I love her smile so much.
6. Kudou Haruka: Her teeth do bother me in certain pictures. But at other times, I think they’re really cute. It depends on the angle and all that. But teeth aside, she’s soooo gorgeous. She has the most amazing eyes and lips. She’s going to be stunning when she’s older; she might even reach the top.
7. Sayashi Riho: She can look a little plain-looking next to the girls with stronger features, but that smile is just amazing. Also, I think she's easily the most photogenic of the new girls. She never looks bad to me. Ever. Even Haruka who I think is super gorgeous takes plenty of awkward pictures. But Riho? Never.
8. Ikuta Erina: Sometimes she smiles awkwardly, and at other times, her smile is just adorable and sunshiney. Always pretty when not smiling.
9. Wada Ayaka: Her teeth and her face shape bother me at times, but mostly, I think she’s really pretty. I like her skin tone, too.
10. Tanaka Reina: Best smile in the history of smiles. Why doesn’t she smile more in pictures? I know they’re messed up on the bottom, but the top row is so charming.
11. Suzuki Airi: Funky teeth, but very pretty when not smiling.
12. Fukuda Kanon: She’s got some pretty ugly teeth, and she knows it because she never smiles with her teeth. But since she never shows her teeth, it’s not a problem because the rest of her face is super pretty.
13. Tamura Meimi: Cute. I love her teeth and I hope she never gets them fixed or at least not for a long time.
14. Natsuyaki Miyabi: I think she’s one of the coolest looking members because of her unusual face shape. Pretty in a different way.
15. Ishida Ayumi: Most of the time, I think her face is too wide and her eyes are weird, but she looks great in videos. Really gorgeous smile and amazing lips. She makes some weird, weird expressions, though, which makes her less attractive, but more endearing. There’s something oddly familiar and sort of comforting about her face.
16. Satou Masaki: Her new haircut makes her look ... not so good, but I think she’s very pretty normally, if a little plain-looking.
17. Tsugunaga Momoko: She makes weird faces that make her chin look too big and her smile is kind of awkward, but if she’s just making a normal face she looks really good. Her lips are so cute.
18. Takeuchi Akari: Not really pretty in a conventional way, but super, super, super cute. Chubby cheeks. <3 She has nice lips, too.
19. Okai Chisato: She’s pretty, but I think she looks best when she’s a little thinner and her hair is long.
20. Hagiwara Mai: Awkward smile and her nose is kind of weird, but very pretty when smirking. Also, being a straight girl, I don’t normally care about bodies, but she’s got a really nice shape to her.
21. Iikubo Haruna: She’s one of those people that doesn’t appeal to me even though most people seem to find her gorgeous. I think she has two things that bother me about her. When her hair is down, her face looks kind of potato-ish. And she’s too bucky. But when her hair is up, she looks really, really cute.
22. Mano Erina: She’s just another one of those people that doesn’t appeal to me even though there’s nothing really wrong with her.
23. Shimizu Saki: Most of the time, she just looks okay, but she looked amazing in the Glass no Pumps performance. Very cool.
24. Suzuki Kanon: A lot of people talk about her smile, but her smile bothers me. I think she’s very pretty when not smiling, though.
25. Tokunaga Chinami: Exactly the same as Kanon.
26. Sudou Maasa: Her teeth bug me, but she looks gorgeous when she’s not smiling.
27. Nakajima Saki: She looks like a monkey when she’s smiling, but she can be very nice-looking when she’s not.
28. Nakanishi Kana: Not really pretty pretty, but sort of cute in a weird way.
29. Katsuta Rina: I know a lot of people find her really unattractive, but she doesn’t bother me. I think she looks like Mano Erina sometimes.

That took FOREVER. I seem to dislike a lot of peoples’ smiles.

Last edited by Panic Nancy on Wed Jul 25, 2012 7:40 am, edited 2 times in total.

[resop2]

My rankings for looks:

1. They're all cute
2. except for the one that looks like a drowned rat ...

[Rm88]

About Yurina's torso, I think it's just the fact that it's rather small compared to her huge hips and legs. But I think that's pretty awesome

[Parhelion69]

P69, I agree with a great many of those assessments, although maybe not in that particular order. Miyalegs = But Zukki? I don't get the hate. I mean, I understand, she's chubby and that is kind of an auto-disqualify for people. But to me, even despite that, she's super-adorable. So genki and bright-eyed, who can resist?

She's not really that ugly (she's better than 80% of AKB ), and is very energetic and funny... or was. Her face looks like she wants to die right here, right now. That's a HUGE downer for me.

Also her being... "big" (to be kind), shows that she gives a damn about herself, her work and MM (another big downer). Since she is really short and thick, looks a bit way too bulky, which isn't easy for the eyes. She seems so out of place around so many good looking girls...

Everything combines and makes an unattractive girl for my eyes.


I've seen one picture when she does look pretty though, so I have hopes that she can turn into a beauty... if she takes care of her looks, that is.