[7/04] Morning Musume 50th: One・Two・Three/ The Matenrou Show

[Rm88]

He's trying so hard to dislike it

[resop2]

^
^
A guy with an opinion?

I actually had no problem with what he said. I did nitpick some fact that he blew in the comments, but everyone is entitled to an opinion.

[Zunu]

Yeah, everyone is entitled to an opinion, but he should recognize that his opinion is not a review. "I don't like that" is not actually criticism, it's just an impression.

[Bakajo Nono]

LET ME REVIEW HIS REVIEW

WHAT YOU'RE TALKING AND ANNOYING AND nevermind I won't do this.

But seriously, what an obnoxious guy. I agree that he is trying really hard to dislike it and picking the actually great parts of the choreography to criticize. P.S. The autotune is awesome and current and a great way to mask the lesser skilled girls' lesser skills.

Also the Haruna bashing is pretty ridiculous. She was obviously changing positions? And seriously dude, she's already in the fucking back. Give her a break.

protip if you feel weird watching Haruka maybe you shouldn't watch Haruka.

[Panic Nancy]

Yeah, that guy ... what he is saying is irritating, but how he is saying it is even more irritating. And I have seen way too many people who act exactly like that guy, which makes it even more irritating. My cousin is one of those people. It's the same obnoxiousness, the same exaggerated expressions, the same trying-too-hard-to-be-funny. I can't stand it.

[Amped]

i'd like to see someone make a counter video about his review. that would be funny.

[Pavlova]

wow, you guys really are stans..

"don't you dare criticize my favorite group!!!1!!"

[Bakajo Nono]

Tbh I think he's being way more stan-ier. He's basically being like "oh my favorite girls left so every single thing sucks now".

[Rm88]

I'm no stan (my stan-ism has Berryz exclusivity) and I'm okay with everyone stating their opinions, but his "review" is silly. And no one is saying he shouldn't voice his negative opinions, but if you upload your opinion on YouTube then people can talk about it, that's probably the whole point. It's just... why did he even bother? That'd be like me reviewing a Lady Gaga song or something. Well, that'd be fun I'd get tons of hateful comments.

[Zunu]

wow, you guys really are stans..

"don't you dare criticize my favorite group!!!1!!"

Um, like I said above, the problem is that he's not criticizing them. He's bashing them.
As wikipedia puts it, "Criticism is the practice of judging the merits and faults of something or someone in an intelligible (or articulate) way."
For the most part, he wasn't judging merits or faults, just saying, "I don't like brown, I don't like autotune, I don't like that dance move...etc." And that's fine to not like stuff. But that's just an opinion piece, not a review, as he called it. As a review, his piece was a failure.