[7/04] Morning Musume 50th: One・Two・Three/ The Matenrou Show

[Jessi]

Yeah I don't get it either. Too young to be on a pachinko machine sure, but on a DVD? They aren't stripteasing they are just sitting on couches singing. I'm betting Tsunku is trying to get people to play on the machines and in a few months after its already leaked on the Internet via fan recordings it will be on YouTube an on a DVD somewhere.

[DARC1993]

Stumbled upon this review of Ｏｎｅ・Ｔｗｏ・Ｔｈｒｅｅ.
I guess he use to be a fan but then all his fav. Left and stuff
It's mostly cristisim so if you are gonna get offended don't watch.
It was funny to me though. It's never bad watching options on something you love.
Poor Haruna gets picked on
[youtube]r1E7TH2U83s[/youtube]
Anyways Ｏｎｅ・Ｔｗｏ・Ｔｈｒｅｅ is still amazing and was handcrafted by god.

[lynnkung]

^ it's not brown, it's chocolate :p

[DARC1993]

It's not chocolate, it's honey. Lol

[questorminator]

Maybe they can release that version as a bonus content in a DVD since this is just an alternate version of the song anyway.

The only other thing I can think of that will make UFA release this version is if there is a widespread clamor from the wotas for it.

[AyuHikaru]

He hates the part of the dance that aren't even bad (Can we talk about that stupid ass hop that forced everyone to change position... while hopping or how stupid the instrumental break choreography is?) I would have arguments with that dude about the choreography

Obligatory: Haruna tries her best okay? Leave my BBY alone ; ;

EDIT: His responses in the comments are pppppppfffftt. He actually said none of the girls have personality, and they all bug him, then went on to say he doesn't follow them anymore. How does he know if they bug him and they have no personality is he DOESN'T ACTIVELY FOLLOW THEM ANYMORE? I hate that logic. Obviously the older girls are better because that's when you followed them so they you paid attention to them more. Hurf durf.

[questorminator]

^
Well, you know, sometimes I wonder why someone would make a review of a song/PV by a group he insists he no longer follows? And it's not just this guy. There are many former fans who do this. I mean, I no longer follow Girls Generation for personal reasons but I don't "review" their songs because I know I would be extremely biased.

At least he took the time to listen to the song. I'll thank him for that even if he didn't like it.

Anyway, regardless of the criticisms by former and current fans about the choreography, the line distribution, or the lack of awesomeness of the current line-up, the song still produced tangible and undeniably great results.

[Jessi]

So not going to watch that video and get myself angry for no reason. That would not be beneficial to me in any way

[questorminator]

^
I agree. Remember that video where a guy called Riho "Ri-whore"? I blame that for elevating my blood pressure forcing me to call in sick. Thankfully I didn't join in the fray (which was getting really nasty) or I might have had a heart attack.

At the end of the day, it's just one guy ranting who just happened to choose a wrong word to describe a then 13-year old girl. It didn't hurt the girl's popularity among Japanese fans neither did it endear her to non-Japanese fans.

And why do I always talk like I'm an old guy? I'm just 29 for Chrissakes....

[rikkikow]

The record sales showed that dude to be a ~ hmmmm ~ a what?
He sure picked the wrong song to show off his knowledge and his wisdom!