by Zunu » Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:47 am
I gave up on WoT (the book series) after book 7? or 8? came out and it just basically consisted of 700-800 pages of the characters running from one end of the world to the other with no plot advancement. There came a point where I just popped out of immersion and the novel turned into a bunch of random A'Postrophe'D W'Ords belched out on the page. I understand that it picked up again after that but I'd already lost interest. That was over 25 years ago (!) so I don't remember the details of the saga at this point. Having said that I've decently enjoyed the two Amazon episodes I've seen so far, judged on their own merits, and not on any adherence or lack thereof to the book plot.
The problem to me is that all of these post-Game of Thrones series just seem derivative and weak by comparison, and that's a function of the source material. George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire," in terms of plot, literary quality, and pacing (at least through the first three books) was just in a league to itself, far beyond Jordan, Bardugo, or any of the other giants of the genre that is Extruded Serial Fantasy Product. So video series that are based upon inferior books inevitably fail to be good enough to be groundbreaking, yet they're not unabashedly silly enough to be as over-the-top fun as something like Xena, although The Witcher comes close in that latter respect. Blah blah blah, Legend of the Seeker, etc., I'm done.
tending to put ~ on song titles since 2002