H!P/etc Ranking Thread

[321BreakinOut]

17. Scramble
18. Te wo Nigitte Arukitai

Those are my Top two Maki' Singles wtf

[Parhelion69]

Oh I want to do the newbies '11 too

1. RihoRiho
2. Eripon
3. Fukuchan
4. Masakissu
5. Ayumi
6. Haruka
7. Haruna
8. Meimi
9. Kana
10. Akari
11. Rina

12. Kanon

lol, I realized I like most of the newer momosu's better than s/mileage ones (I love S/mileage btw), I just don't care about zukki, she doesn't FEEL like an idol, doesn't have the looks, isn't very talented, and I don't find her particularly funny (Eripon makes me laugh much, much more). I don't hate her though, I just think she isn't H!P material... Maybe she'll prove me wrong in the future though (I hope that happens)

Oh, and 9th gen rules them all.

[otaku_blue]

Pro to Noob:
1. Sayashi Riho
2. Takechan
3. Ishida Ayumi
4. Meimei
5. Fukuchan
6. Haruna
7. Haruka
8. Erina
9. Rina
10. Kanon
11. Masaki
12. Kana

Haruna's modelling career definitely surpasses Haruka imo, just needs to improve her dancing.

Despite Rina's unnecessary involvement with S/mileage she's still more talented than Kana.

Contrary to many Meimi haters she's a lot more skilled and trained than most of the other noobies.

[Starra]

Berryz singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Otabeki Boy WAO!
2. Gag 100kaibun Aishite Kudasai
3. Watashi no Mirai no Dannasama
4. Anata Nashi de wa Ikite Yukenai
5. Fighting Pose wa Date ja nai!
6. Dschinghis Khan
7. Dakishimete Dakishimete
8. Heroine ni Narou ka!
9. Maji Bomber!!
10. Special Generation
11. Seishun Bus Guide
12. Tsukiatteru no ni Kataomoi

Like:
13. Jiriri Kiteru
14. Koi no Jubaku
15. Kokuhaku no Funsui Hiroba
16. VERY BEAUTY
17. Yuke Yuke Monkey Dance
18. Ai no Dangan
19. Ryuusei Boy

Meh:
20. Shining Power
21. Nanchuu Koi wo Yatteruu YOU KNOW?
22. Piriri to Yukou!

Dislike:
23. Waracchaou yo BOYFRIEND
24. MADAYADE
25. Munasawagi Scarlet
26. Aa, Yo ga Akeru

Hate:
27. Rival
28. 21ji Made no Cinderella
29. Tomodachi wa Tomodachi nan da!
30. Happiness〜Koufuku Kangei!〜

℃-ute singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Sekai Ichi HAPPY na Onna no Ko
2. Aitai Lonely Christmas
3. Bye Bye Bye!
4. SHOCK!
5. Campus Life〜Umarete Kite Yokatta〜
6. LALALA Shiawase no Uta
7. Momoiro Sparkling
8. Soku Dakishimete

Like:
9. Tokaikko Junjou
10. Massara Blue Jeans
11. Shochuu Omimai Moushiagemasu
12. Wakkyanai (Z)
13. Ooki na Ai de Motenaishite
14. Meguru Koi no Kisetsu

Dislike:
15. Edo no Temari Uta Ⅱ
16. Sakura Chirari
17. EVERYDAY Zekkouchou!!

Hate:
18. Dance de Bakoon!
19. Kiss me Aishiteru
20. Koero! Rakuten Eagles
21. FOREVER LOVE
22. Namida no Iro

Buono! singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Take It Easy!
2. Kiss! Kiss! Kiss!
3. Gachinkou de Ikou!
4. Natsu Dakara!
5. Our Songs

Like:
6. Renai♥Rider
7. Lotta Love Lotta Love
8. co・no ・mi・chi

Hate:
9. Bravo☆Bravo
10. Honto no Jibun
11. Zassou no Uta
12. MY BOY

Mano Erina singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Love&Peace=Paradise
2. Genkimono de Ikou!
3. Sekai wa Summer Party
4. Manopiano
5. Seishun no Serenade
6. My Days for You

Like:
7. Kono Mune no Tokimeki wo
8. Onegai Dakara...
9. Hajimete no Keiken

Meh:
10. Haru no Arashi
11. Otome no Inori

Dislike:
12. Lucky Aura
13. Lalala-Sososo

S/mileage singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. ◯◯Ganbaranakutemo Ee nen de!!
2. Asu wa Date na no ni, Imasugu Koe ga Kikitai
3. Uchouten LOVE
4. Yumemiru Fifteen

Like:
5. Sukichan
6. Short Cut

Meh:
7. Tachiagirl
8. Koi ni Booing Buu!

Dislike:
9. Otona ni Narutte Muzukashii!!!
10. Onaji Jikyuu de Hataraku Tomodachi no Bijin Mama
11. aMa no Jaku

Heike Michiyo singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Daikirai
2. GET
3. Murasaki Shikibu
4. One Room Natsu no Koi Monogatari

Like:
5. Anata no Yume ni Naritai
6. Dakedo Aishisugite
7. Kekkyoku Bye Bye Bye
8. Sotsugyou〜TOP OF THE WORLD〜

Dislike:
9. scene
10. Propose
11. Ai no Chikara

Nakazawa Yuuko singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Urara
2. Kuyashi Namida Porori
3. Dannasama
4. Odaiba Moonlight Serenade
5. Karasu no Nyoubou
6. Futarigurashi

Like:
7. Shanghai no Kaze
8. Tokyo Bijin

Dislike:
9. GET ALONG WITH YOU
10. Nagaragawa no Hare
11. Junjou Koushinkyoku
12. Genki no Nai Hi no Komoriuta
13. DO MY BEST

Abe Natsumi singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Iki wo Kasanemashou
2. Screen
3. The・Stress
4. Too far away〜Onna no Kokoro〜
5. 22sai no Watashi
6. Koi no Telephone GOAL

Like:
7. 16sai no Koi nante
8. Takaramono
9. Amasugita Kajitsu
10. Haha to Musume no Duet Song
11. Yume Naraba

Dislike:
12. Ameagari no Niji no You ni
13. Koi no Hana
14. Datte Ikitekanakucha

Hate:
15. Sweetholic

Fujimoto Miki singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Boogie Train '03
2. Okitegami

Like:
3. Romantic Ukare Mode
4. Aenai Nagai Nichiyoubi

Dislike:
5. Sotto Kuchizukete Gyutto Dakishimete
6. Boyfriend

Maeda Yuki singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Gwenchana〜Daijoubu〜
2. Busan Hatsu
3. Tokyo, Yoimachigusa。
4. Omae no Namida wo Ore ni Kure

Like:
5. Mianeyo〜Gomennasai〜
6. Ai Ai Daiko

Meh:
7. Naki Usagi
8. Tokyo Kirigirisu
9. Tokyo You Turn

Dislike:
10. Nishi Shinjuku de Atta Hito
11. Sarasara no Kawa

Matsuura Aya singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. ♡Momoiro Kataomoi♡
2. Kizuna
3. Egao
4. THE LAST NIGHT
5. Hyacinth
6. GOOD BYE Natsuo
7. LOVE Namidairo

Like:
8. Watarasebashi
9. Kiseki no Kaori Dance。
10. Yeah! Meccha Holidday
11. 100kai no Kiss

Meh:
12. Suna wo Kamu You ni... NAMIDA
13. Ki ga Tsukeba Anata
14. Zutto Suki de Ii desu ka

Dislike:
15. Neee
16. The Bigaku
17. Dokkidoki! LOVE Mail
18. Tropical Koishiteeru
19. Tensai! LET'S GO Ayayamu

Hate:
20. Sougen no Hito
21. YOUR SONG〜Seishun Sensei〜
22. Futari Osaka
23. Chocolate Damashii

Taiyou to Ciscomoon/T&C Bomber singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Everyday Everywhere
2. Uchuu de La Ta Ta
3. Gatamekira
4. Magic of Love

Like:
5. Marui Taiyou -winter ver.-
6. DON'T STOP Renaichuu
7. HEY! Mahiru no Shinkirou

Meh:
8. Tsuki to Taiyou

W singles:

Spoiler: show

Love:
1. Koi no Vacance
2. Koi no Fugue

Like:
3. Aa Ii na!
4. Robokiss

Dislike:
5. Miss Love Tantei
6. Ai no Imi wo Oshiete!

[Parhelion69]

^i just took the chore of looking at your favorites and it's incredible how opposites are my favs xD I love some of your "hates" and I hate some of your favs, but that's the good thing that there's lots of variation withing everyone's singles, there's always something to like (I hate generic jpop, so that'd be most of it, and that's why I like H!P music so much, it's never the same thing)

[Rm88]

I'm doing Berryz. It's tough, I love all their singles:

Spoiler: show

1- Maji Bomber!!
2- Shining Power
3- Ryuusei Boy
4- Otakebi Boy WAO!
5- Yuke Yuke Monkey Dance
6- Kokuhaku no Funsui Hiroba
7- VERY BEAUTY
8- Rival
9- MADAYADE
10- Seishun Bus Guide
11- Gag 100kaibun Aishite Kudasai
12- Tomodachi wa Tomodachi Nanda!
13- Waracchaou yo BOYFRIEND
14- Tsukiatteru no ni Kataomoi
15- Munasawagi Scarlet
16- Jingisukan
17- Ai no Dangan
18- Heroine ni Narou ka!
19- Fighting Pose wa Date ja nai!
20- Jiriri Kiteru
21- Koi no Jubaku
22- Dakishimete Dakishimete
23- Nanchuu Koi wo Yatteruu YOU KNOW?
24- Happiness ~Koufuku Kangei~
25- Watashi no Mirai no Dannasama
26- Aa, Yo ga Akeru
27- Anata Nashi de wa Ikite Yukenai
28- Special Generation
29- Piriri to Yukou!
30- 21ji Made no Cinderella

Almost no gaps, and I love 21ji Made so yeah

And a top 5 for the rest of the current groups:

Spoiler: show

°C-ute:
1- Campus Life ~Umarete Kite Yokatta~
2- Edo no Temari Uta II
3- Bye Bye Bye!
4- Sekai Ichi HAPPY na Onna no Ko
5- FOREVER LOVE

Buono!:
1- Natsu Dakara!
2- Our Songs
3- co.no.mi.chi
4- Take it Easy!
5- Rottara Rottara

Mano:
1- Kono Mune no Tokimeki wo
2- Genkimono de Ikou!
3- Love & Peace = Paradise
4- Otome no Inori
5- Haru no Arashi

S/mileage:
1- Onaji Jikyuu de Hataraku Tomodachi no Bijin Mama
2- Shortcut
3- ◯◯Ganbaranakutemo Ee nen de!!
4- Yume Miru 15sai
5- Koi ni Booing Buu!

Morning Musume:
1- Aruiteru
2- Happy Summer Wedding
3- Hyokkori Hyoutanjima
4- AS FOR ONE DAY
5- Kanashimi Twilight

[Panic Nancy]

Has anyone ever tried ranking all of the girls in H!P from best to worst according to singing ability? It might be difficult, but I think that would be interesting. Just to clarify, I’m not talking how much you like the girl’s voice, but how good of a singer you think she really is (relative to the others). These two get confused sometimes. I’d post my ranking now, but it’s not ready. I'd like to see other peoples' first.

[resop2]

^
Don't hold your breath waiting for mine. Rating idols by singing ability to me is as relevant as rating them by their ability to do a running high jump.

[Pavlova]

Has anyone ever tried ranking all of the girls in H!P from best to worst according to singing ability? It might be difficult, but I think that would be interesting. Just to clarify, I’m not talking how much you like the girl’s voice, but how good of a singer you think she really is (relative to the others). These two get confused sometimes. I’d post my ranking now, but it’s not ready. I'd like to see other peoples' first.

FMM did it at some point. I remember disagreeing entirely with her ranking.

[Sohee]

I would do it, but I can't really stand ranking beyond 10.