Celedam wrote:Regarding four-year contracts, you can't count just from when they debut to when they graduate. You must add some time to the front to allow for recruitment, relocation, and orientation, and you must add some time to the back to allow for business arrangements to be concluded. And when you do that, it's pretty consistently four years, even for Junjun and Linlin.
As for my reaction to the news itself: I'm not surprised. She didn't develop much of a character, she didn't make much of an impact in the group, and her performance didn't improve much over those four years, so I didn't see how she could have much of a future with Up-Front. Being an idol was a fun after-school job for her and nothing more.
How could I forget Jun/Lin !! That also really cements the contracts idea and yeah I knew I wasn’t the only one who had thought about it. I remember 9th gen having to fill out a bunch of paperwork when they joined and Riho remarking that she had joined “the world of adults”
As for Hacchin, I wish her the best. I think it’s up to the individual as to whether they can juggle both as Ayacho managed just fine, while others felt they didn’t want to be half hearted. I support her decision, but I also agree that she didn’t grow or stand out. I get the impression the other three 12ki are just catapillars that will one day become butterflies. They remind me of 6ki who joined when the group was already pretty large and full of popular girls ... it took some time but now the 6kis have a legacy that is unmatched within Morning Musume.
Also I was watching a performance the other day and thought man this group has gotten way too large. It’s makes the dances look messy and less impressive. And if I had to downsize id pick Ogata to go. (Can I also clarify that “least fav” in my fav group of all time really means very little. I don’t hate her I just never found myself very interested in her.)